Hi again...should have also mentioned by other dilemma! Can't decide on the type of newel that would work best. I'm attaching pictures of the 2 I'm considering - as you will see, they are both very different! One is more understated and modern - I like it , but I think the house might be too traditional for this?? I like the fluted look of the other newel, and think it is more traditional, although I'm not sure about the skirt at the bottom - and wondering, if it might be too traditional - leading to old fashioned?? I'm considering square spindles for this one and square or metal spindles for the first one. Again, any recommendations or other ideas, would be very appreciated! Thanks.

You are correct in they are two totally different styles. The traditional sounds like the way to head considering the style of he rest of the house. When heading in the modern direction it starts change the style of the whole home, furniture for one. This stair change can be a major design change. If you are heading in that direction over a long term time, getting modern furnishings, changing molding and such this would be the time. Another though or question to ask yourself is how long to you plan to stay there vs possible resell in five years or so.

Link of Traditional & Contemporary styles http://www.portlandstaircompany.com/portfolio