Issue with Carrara tile - need advice
My master bathroom renovation has been a bit of a struggle due to various issues - including having to rip out my shower pan and start over due to improper construction.
My contractor ordered 150 sf of 3” x 9” Carrara tile for my shower walls + wainscoting for tub surround (included 20% extra tile for cuts and culling). I opened most of the boxes a few weeks ago in order to confirm background color + veining. The tiles look beautiful (photo was taken with shades down (3 p.m.) - looks prettier in person):


Unfortunately, the remaining boxes looked NOTHING like the ones I had opened previously (random pull of tile from three of the remaining boxes and one of the previously opened boxes):

This photo was taken outside around 3 p.m. (Eastern indirect sunlight). I’m pretty sure that I don’t need to tell you which row is from one of the opened boxes . . .
Contractor spoke with tile retailer - manager doesn’t know what happened and apologized profusely. My contractor said that it looks like the rejects of lower grade Carrara tile (as if someone went through boxes and returned bad tiles). Tile retailer will replace boxes + offered 20% discount. The issue is that it will take a few weeks to receive replacement boxes.
I already had to wait several weeks for tile setter to have availability. He is a replacement after the initial one engaged by contractor (not one of contractor‘s normal tile setters) incorrectly built shower pan. If tile setter can’t start this upcoming Monday, I will have to wait until he can squeeze me in (not until end of September unless someone cancels).
I have been trying to come up with alternate ideas. FYI - I have a designer (she is my daughter’s best friend - and does not have much experience - I hired her to help build her portfolio) - I am going to discuss ideas with her tomorrow. Basically, I am trying to figure out a way to replace some of the 3 x 9 Carrara tile with some other material.
1. Replace tile wainscoting around bathtub with one of the following:
A. painted wainscoting (either with or without Carrara accent tile listello) -

B. Full accent wall (not sure exactly what it will look like but similar to below):

C. Carrara/glass mosaic tile wainscoting (I already have this mosaic tile - have been thinking about using it on wall behind vanity - it’s clear glass + frosted glass + carrara):

D. Wall with wainscoting + recessed shelving (I have a lot of room behind wall that can be used to add built-in storage) -

2. Mix current 3x9 Carrara tiles on the shower walls with one of the following:
A. Different size carrara tiles (larger size tiles can be delivered ASAP - can use 3x9 on shower walls as wainscoting with other size above + use 3x9 carrara tiles for wainscoting around tub.

B. Same idea as above but instead of another size of Carrara tile, mix 3x9 Carrara tiles with either thassos marble or white porcelain tile -

C. Mix 3x9 Carrara tiles with a marble mosaic tile on shower walls -

D. Use marble mosaic accent tile in niche + around niche on longest shower wall (more of wall would be covered with marble mosaic accent tile than in this photo in order to be able to use 3x9 tiles around tub) -

3. A genius idea that’s better than any of the ones I’ve thought of above (my brain hurts + I’m not that creative).
I will add photos of the bathroom in its current state in a separate post below.
I hope this makes sense - I haven’t slept AT ALL for two days. I’m not thinking very clearly at the moment. Thanks!
Comments (30)
- 5 years ago
So sorry you've ended up in this situation! My vote would be for the accent wall rather than mixing tile types, but I'd want to see photos of the current space and what you originally intended before making up my mind.
dani_m08 thanked User - 5 years ago
Nobody can answer this without knowing exactly the amount of tile required for each of the areas planned to have the tile.
Post the FLOOR plan.for the bath, with all the dimensions.
I would not add accent tile to anything .
Related Professionals
Utica Home Remodeling · Ontario Home Remodeling · Salinas Kitchen Remodelers · Hartford Bathroom Remodelers · Morgantown Interior Designers & Decorators · Chillicothe Interior Designers & Decorators · Jacksonville Architects & Building Designers · Flint Architects & Building Designers · Vicksburg Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Murrieta Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Albany Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Lima Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Greenville Tile and Stone Contractors · Brooklyn Tile and Stone Contractors · Middletown Tile and Stone Contractors- 5 years ago
Are you completely without a bathroom or just inconvenienced by having to use/share another? If you have the luxury of being able to use another bathroom I say wait it out and get what you planned for. If the latter then yes Jan is right - more info needed.
- 5 years ago
I wouldn’t add anything to your design. Follow through with your original game plan. And do the marble tile you wanted.
The only thing I personally would consider is doing wallpaper somewhere. But that would have to be waterproof wallpaper, steam resistant, and you may have to wait for a special order on that too ...dani_m08 thanked HU-187528210 dani_m08
Original Author5 years agoI knew that I should have waited to post this until after I had some sleep!
@JAN MOYER - I have enough ”good” tile for the entire shower - OR - part of the shower + the tub surround - but not enough for both. I know that you have told others that they don’t need to tile around bathtub. My plan was to have wall mounted faucet for tub - however, a deck mounted faucet also works with my tub. I could just do regular wainscoting + a small backsplash. I’ve seen photos like that - I’ll have to find some to post.
Here is the floor plan:
The floor plan was drawn ”as existing” before renovations began. The existing custom tiled shower + jacuzzi tub + vanity were all removed. I posted a discussion before the project began re: whether I should (i) use part of the closet in order to increase the length of the shower, and (ii) keep existing jacuzzi tub. I already knew that I wanted to rip out jacuzzi - just wanted to show SO that the majority of people also dislike jacuzzi tubs! Consensus was that a 47” x 42” shower was large enough so I didn’t incorproate any of the closet.
Here is the current state of the bathroom:
from door between bathroom and bedroom (pocket door is being added to closet):
Ceiling is 9’ by closet door and vaults to 11’:

Rest of area for bathtub (tub is a back-to-wall so flush against wall with no open floor space to clean behind tub + there is over 11” of floor space on each side of tub):
Custom floating vanity in alcove (wiring being changed for wall sconces):

- 5 years ago
I like the idea of mixing tile sizes - use the tile you have for the shower and do a larger tile 12 x 24 or even 24 x 48 for the tub so it almost looks like slabs on the walls..
Just a thought..
dani_m08 thanked Debbi Washburn dani_m08
Original Author5 years agolast modified: 5 years ago@thinkdesignlive - Well, here’s the rest of the story:
I do have other bathrooms - and have actually been using my guest bedroom + bathroom for the past few months while all of this has been going on in order to avoid dust (I have pretty serious health issues - so, it seemed like a good idea to vacate that complete area).
I would rather just wait - after all, I moved out of my bedroom the last week of March - a couple more months won’t kill me.
HOWEVER, my sister is preparing to leave an abusive marriage. I prepared a ”Protection From Abuse Order” - and it will be filed TOMORROW. So, my sister and two nieces will be staying with me for a bit. One niece will be heading back up to college in a few weeks - the other is 17.
This is why I’m trying so desperately to come up with an alternate plan for my bathroom. While we can figure out a way to get through a couple weeks without the use of my master bathroom, I just don’t know how long that’s actually feasible.
This is also why I haven’t been sleeping. Stress greatly affects my health issues = a TON of pain = no sleep.
And this is also why I probably sound a bit ”crazy” in my posts.
dani_m08
Original Author5 years agolast modified: 5 years ago@Debbi Washburn - Wow - you read my mind! I knew that I forgot to include one of my ideas - and this was it!
I was thinking the same thing about trying to use a LFT as the tub surround. I love how marble slabs look - but that’s not in the budget! Unless someone knows where I can find one of these for a good price + have it shipped for free to my house! 😂


- 5 years agolast modified: 5 years ago
Sounds like WAY more serious issues than a bath delay -
I'd hold on the bath, and make this a short term stay for your sister. .....if only because this sounds like a need for very SECURE protection . Don't compromise your own safety. Get some help from the local services available. It could turn to you needing protection, in a single heartbeat.
My advice? Finish the tile to completion in the shower. Send BACK the free standing tub. You don't have the space........and forgive for truth?
Your SO is not a bath designer: ) and I am being kind. I am quite sure he is wonderful in many other ways. Two shower heads were not necessary or advisable, and nor was the tub. Delay, get a bath designer to help you get back on track with the tile and where shall be what other tile or wainscoting or solid surface. I can barely see the comments you posted. ( the text on the photos )
Remember too, that dinosaurs like myself shared a bath growing up.......with FOUR other folks. - and nobody died. : ) Consider it was a mere 5 x 9 feet as well.
- 5 years ago
I am so sorry you are going through all that. Things will get better. This is a bathroom. Many of us grew up with lots of people and just one bath. Somehow it works out.
Finish your shower with the tile you have . Then either go with a larger format tile for the tub or do the wainscot panel. Simplify your choices. All that other stuff was just too much - too many ideas thrown into the space.
This is a shower with one size tile and a larger tile for the tub.

I did notice you have a different color floor tile though. That would make me lean toward the wainscot - I think you need the "pause" in the design.
Finish the bathroom and move forward with your family. It is not worth making yourself sick over it. Take care of yourself and good luckdani_m08 thanked Debbi Washburn - 5 years ago
I don’t know where you live but here in Indy - Coburn Place has been a godsend for families like your sisters. Maybe they can link you to a place by you. Jan was right - you need to think safety first for all and these places know how to guide you. Best of luck to you.
dani_m08 thanked thinkdesignlive - 5 years ago
Things like this really put life in perspective. There are much more important thig than agonizing over the perfect shade of white.
I truly wish you and your family all the best - sending positive thoughts your way!
dani_m08
Original Author5 years ago@Debbi Washburn - My mind was going in a hundred different directions when I wote my post. I was frantically trying to come up with a solution - because I was feeling frantic about what’s going on with my sister/nieces. Not the best way to make design decisions.
The floor in the bathroom is slate tile - 4x12 - in a herringbone pattern. I chose that after seing photos of many bathrooms with marble showers and slate floors.
I think that the best answer is to simply tile the shower - and do a simple wainscoting around the tub. Also, I do also have a designer - however, she’s my daughter’s best friend and only recently started her career - not much experience but I waned to help build her portfolio. She will be back in town tomorrow - and has been thinking about possible ideas.
I just filed the requst for the protection from abuse order. I truly appreciate everyone’s well wishes. FYI - one of my neighbors is a retired FBI agent. We’ve added a Ring video doorbell + alarm system + motion detectors + a few well placed surveillance cameras. My local police station is pretty close to my home + one of my other sisters lives just a few minutes away. My ex husband (we are very close friends) is an assistant district attorney and has developed some close relationships with local law enforcement officers - there will be hourly scheduled “drive-bys” in order to both watch the house, plus also to have a visible police presence. I also just spoke with my sister’s FIL - he’s going to step in and head over to have a conversation with his son.- 5 years ago
"Contractor spoke with tile retailer - manager doesn’t know what happened and apologized profusely. My contractor said that it looks like the rejects of lower grade Carrara tile (as if someone went through boxes and returned bad tiles). Tile retailer will replace boxes + offered 20% discount. The issue is that it will take a few weeks to receive replacement boxes."
We also just experienced this with a client selected national "tile retailer" who caters to DIY and non professionals. dani_m08
Original Author5 years ago@Jeffrey R. Grenz, General Contractor - I would have been much less upset/surprised if I had sourced some Chinese marble from HD! I have a friend who’s mom or sister (?) purchased marble from HD or L a few years ago. She said that the bathroom looked nice - but apparently she spent several days w her mom/sister rummaging through boxes at several different locations in order to find enough tiles to install. I feel fortunate to have a budget that allowed me to avoid having to resort to doing that.
The diamond mosaic tile that I thought about using on my vanity wall is from a big box store - and it actually looks pretty nice. My contractor was surprised that it was only $15 sf. Not sure where/if I’m going to use it - maybe on fireplace in my bedroom. I never would have found it if someone hadn’t used it for a backsplash here on Houzz:

Apparently, not all marble materials from big box retailers are low quality.
When my daughter picked it up for me, I asked her to look at the marble field tiles. Here’s a pic she sent me:
Definitely NOT the type of ”Carrara” marble that I wanted - WAY TOO GRAY - and a bit too crazy veining.
I had read many posts from all of you pros about the difference in the quality of marble at big box stores vs. tile sourced by contractor/design professional - you guys weren’t exaggerating! The tiles from my ”normal” boxes were surprisingly white (iPhone makes them look grayer for some reason) and the veining is beautiful :
The retailer where my tiles were sourced is one that is very highly regarded here on Houzz. I think that’s why I didn’t feel the need to go through all of the boxes.
Lesson learned - plan ahead for the unexpected.- 5 years agodani_m08 thanked Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
- 5 years ago
"The retailer where my tiles were sourced is one that is very highly regarded here on Houzz. I think that’s why I didn’t feel the need to go through all of the boxes."
F&D? What retailer is highly regarded on Houzz? dani_m08
Original Author5 years agolast modified: 5 years ago@Diana Bier Interiors, LLC - REALLY looks nice! Where did you have your glass window made?I need (okay, want) to have one made for the transom window over my front door.
Initially, I planned on doing the wainscoting + doing something similar to what you’ve done on the vanity wall. When my designer suggested using a tile wainscoting around the tub, I decided to just do tile in both places.
I’ve bought a lot of tile! There are SO MANY beautiful tiles that I couldn’t decide which to use (or where). Becuase I wasn’t feeling up to going to any tile showrooms - and needed to make a decision quickly, I purchased a few different accent tiles for the vanity wall. Kinda funny considering that it’s now the middle of July, and the only tile that’s been installed is on the floor!
What I really want to install on the wall behind my the vanity is this:

I know - it’s too much with the marble tile in the shower - I guess it will have to go in one of my other bathrooms . . .Q - my ceiling vaults from about 9’ to 11’ over the shower - the plan is to tile up to the ceiling along the vault

This is a sketch I made before the project started - when I was trying to decide if I wanted a niche/accent tile feature on the back wall. I like when showers are tiled up to the ceiling vs. leaving some wall space between end of tile and ceiling (as was done in my previous shower). I‘ve read some comments that recommend not tiling up to the ceiling if it’s too high because it emphasizes the height too much.
My designer said that If the ceilings were 11’ along the entire back wall, she would recommend only tiling up 9’ along this wall - but since it’s a vault, I could do it either way. I decided to take the tile up to the ceiling on that wall + on the partial wall between the shower and tub area. What do you think?dani_m08
Original Author5 years ago@Jeffrey R. Grenz, General Contractor - I don’t know if I should feel insulted by your comments or not.
It seemed like the purpose of your initial comment was to tell me that the reason I had issues with my marble tile is because I decided to source it myself from a big box store. I then decided that maybe I was reading too much into it. I’ve read SO MANY comments on here where a homeowner is having issues with their tile installation and IMMEDIATELY reveives comments from pros (and some non-pros) about how she/he shouldn’t have (i) hired a hack, and/or (ii) bought cheap chinese crap. Basically, in MANY comments, the homeowner is blamed for whatever issue has occured due to being a cheapskate.
I decided NOT to infer any hidden meaning in your initial comment. However, after reading your second comment, I’m not sure what to think.
1. I am not doing this DIY. The renovation is being completed by a licensed, well respected professional who does not have to source materials from a big box store who caters to nonprofessionals. As I’ve already disclosed above, I have a designer - she’s young and inexperienced, but she did go to school in order to work in this field. I also explained in my initial post that my contractor ordered the tile - I didn’t have anything to do with this part other than selecting the type of material.
2. I did not hire a hack. My GC initially had to use a subcontractor that was new to him due to scheduling conflicts. Unfortunately, that was a BAD decision - and my shower pan had to be ripped out. The whole reason my project has been delayed for months is because I decided to wait until a highly recommended tile professional had an opening in his schedule.
3. The diamond marble/glass mosaic tile backsplash in the kitchen photos I posted are from F&D. I saw a Houzz user’s photos (included in my above comment) that she posted of her lovely new kitchen, and inquired where she bought her backsplash tiles. She told me that she found them at F&D. Based upon the amount of negative comments from certain pros on here, I was under the impression that all (most?) tiles from F&D were ”seconds” and/or low quality.
One of the reasons my contractor was surprised that the mosaic tiles were from F&D is because the glass does not have the green tint that many white/clear tiles have due to the iron content. When I intially told him that I had my daughter purchase some glass mosaic tile from F&D, he told me to search for “green tint issues after installation” on here. He was concerned that once the tile was installed, I would be very unhappy because it “changed“ colors.
4. As I’ve already explained above, I feel lucky that my budget allowed me to not have to source marble tile from a big box retailer. F&D is a big box retailer. The photo of the marble I didn’t like in my above post was taken by my daughter when she went to F&D to look at the diamond marble/glass mosaic tile for me.
So, either you think I’m “ignorant” and don’t realize that F&D is a big box retailer, OR that I’m lying because I don’t want to admit that I bought my tile from HD/L/F&D . . .
Believe me - if I could have bought the marble tiles shown in the above photos (same quality) from a big box retailer, I would have in a heartbeat! While I’m not a cheapskate, I absolutely LOVE getting a ”deal” on something! FWIW, I recently bought a light fixture that is IDENTICAL to one that I saw in a blog from Resoration Hardware. It was $2,700 at RH. I bought mine for $350 from Lamps Plus. FYI - I never shop at RH/Pottery Barn for EXACTLY this reason - CRAZY MARKUPS!
I am also not the type of person who is too good/cool/whatever to purchase something from a big box store - if it’s of equal or better quality. In fact, if I had purchased my marble from a big box store I would have BRAGGED about the deal I got! In fact, I have bragged on Houzz about an online purchase I made from a big box store several months ago, Discontiuned item - bought it “sight unseen“ - and it turned out to be an incredible purchase.
When I re-read my initial post, I did see something that needs clarification. The retailer did not just offer a 20% discount on the “good” boxes, they also offered to supply replacement boxes for the bad tile at a really good discount (only meaningful if I decided to wait on my tile installation in order to include the tile wainscoting around the tub).
Lastly, the reason I haven’t named the ”highly regarded retailer” is because I honestly believe that what happened is a fluke of some sort. There is NO WAY this particular tile source has the reputation it holds if this is something that occurs at times. I don’t want to this post to have any type of possible negative effect re: future customers. I tend to be particularly “sensitive“ regarding this type of thing because I have a sister who is a co-owner of several boutique clothing stores. A retailer shouldn’t suffer negative consequences simply because something went wrong. There will always be some issues - what really matters is how those issues are handled.
FYI - I did think about how linking their name to how the situation is being handled would be a positive for them - however, we all know that the negative comments/reviews receive way more attention/weight than the positive ones.dani_m08
Original Author5 years agolast modified: 5 years ago@Jeffrey R. Grenz, General Contractor- FYI - I didn’t sleep last night - I am cranky. If I am reading too much into your comments, I apologize.
- 5 years ago
So sorry you are going thru all this. Hope all goes well! Im not a pro but I would use the good tiles in the shower and either large tile behind tub or the wainscoting. I really like the recessed shelves that you posted!
dani_m08 thanked Becky H - 5 years agolast modified: 5 years ago
@dani_m08, not sure where you're located but I used a local glass company, Excalibur Art Glass in East Rockaway, NY to fabricate the leaded glass panel.
As for your other questions, I would rely on the designer, since she is the one who is on site and sees everything in real life!
dani_m08 thanked Diana Bier Interiors, LLC - 5 years agolast modified: 5 years ago
@dani_m08 Sorry for the misunderstanding.
Your materials look awesome except for the stone batch(s) that didn't match. My brother had a good experience with ceramic tiles from the vendor.
I didn't want to throw a retailer under the bus until I understood if it was the same. This was our first experience also. A costly one. We are learning with you. We also had to reorder one floor, still was not as expected. We demoed and reset a portion of another floor. Starting to see a pattern in their standards.
My more civil tile contractor says "their stock is picked through"
My less reserved tile contractor would only install with a sign off after seeing it. Also noted their setting materials are more expensive.
In the future we will require a sign off prior to ordering and will increase our "waste" factors for this vendor when ordering stone, off setting some of the discount pricing while mitigating our added costs.
I wouldn't have expected it as some of their reps had visited the custom home developments and pitched a few months ago. Their stores are big, clean and shiny just like a top retailer, so its confusing. - 5 years ago
I also like the wainscoting behind the tub idea, no matter how many more marble tiles you have. I did a marble bathroom in my last house using standard subway tiles in a herringbone pattern on the floor and large 12x12 tiles in the shower. My designer suggested wainscoting around the room (no tub, just a shower) and it was perfect. FYI - Benjamin Moore Quiet Moments looks good with carrera marble. (My floor wasn’t dark slate.)
I think you can keep moving forward with the wainscoting plan OR the large format tiles in the shower.I’m glad you can help protect your family - all of you! And sharing the bathrooms for a couple of months won’t kill anyone. That is more important than a new bathroom but I understand you just want it done and done right.
- 5 years agolast modified: 5 years ago
I like the idea of doing the wainscoting tub surround. But, why couldn’t you simply finish up your shower with the good tile and wait to do the tub surround when the rest of the good tile comes in? This will at least give you a working shower for when your sister is there and you don’t really NEED a working tub immediately, so could hold off on that. It’s a pain to have to wait, but at least this way you will have a usable shower and in the long run get the bathroom you originally wanted.
@Diana Bier Interiors, LLC …..LOVE your bathroom!
dani_m08 thanked User













Debbi Washburn