I like these two. Gorgeous kitchen!!

Try Jacobean and Dark Walnut.

You need a pretreatment first. Two coats of Ciranova pink blocker for first time users. Then you could apply the color you want, whichever that may be.

What is the look you're trying to achieve? I see grays and browns.

Thanks! I’m looking for a light brown that will work with the island but also minimizing red tones as much as possible.

Pink Blocker will "minimize" your red tones. For light browns, you will not have much to choose from in Duraseal colors. Bona has Twig or Nutmeg in Drifast stains. If, you want lighter than that, use chemical stains.

I do not like the grey and the browns look very similar to the island. Can you keep it lighter? More natural but not pink/red?

After all of that I took @apple_pie_order advice and did 3 equal parts Dark Walnut, Jacobean and Neutral. I love them!

What does it look like against the island?

We aren’t there but it looks good in the picture.

Here it is from a distance