Have you tried a sample of the paint when its color matched. It could very well be called some type of gray. I would get a sample and try it, to see if it actually does match. Yes, I see the greeny appearance, but, some grays, can take on that exact look. They also can look different in other areas, so you need to try it right next to what you already have.

The problem is I don’t have a sample. I just found this house in photos.

The builder doesn't remember the name but describes it as a "rustic green."

Here's another view:

0304 New Residence · More Info

I color snapped:

Another to try, that's more green SW 2846 Roycroft Bronze Green

https://www.textbookpainting.com/refreshed-exterior-painting-in-lakewood/

@CD7733 You are the BEST!! It has been driving me crazy. I keep buying and trying samples and it just wasn't right. Off to the store I go!

I don't know how you did it but can you also tell me the trim color?

SW 6041 Otter looks close

I would not have guess that it was brown.

cd7733 You have absolutely made my day. Thanks again!

My house is SW 6173 Cocoon…more green. That pic for sure more brown in it.

@Molly is Cocoon your base or trim?

I have SW 6172 Hardware lap siding and 6173 Cocoon on my shakes with white trim.

i like the Muddled Basil above. Can you post a picture of the house and maybe that will generate more ideas?

@cd7733 Can you tell me what the trim is on the other muddled basil house you posted with the light trim.

The description from the builder above with Muddled Basil says

SW7744 Zeus

@Molly D. Zone4B Thank you. I'm embarrassed that I didn't see that. I now have 6 quarts of paint and 3 color combinations. Surely I will love one of them.

No problem. That builder Highmark on that house is near me and is very good. For more ideas look at their profile

Try Roycroft bronze green. Sherwin Williams