White with black trim would look beautiful! Have you considered updating your lighting to something a little more substantial? Some larger lanterns on the garage and porch would look nice with the colors you are proposing. Your new house has beautiful bones!

I new front door not Victorian .Are you thinking modern farmhouse look? IMO the garge doors need some work to get rid of the angled corners if you plan that simple high contrast color scheme. I would also think about window replacement with ideally no grids or just a simple double hung with less grids sort of like these I aslo love the idea of some wood and maybe the garge doors with some windows would be agood idea

Budget? Scope of work you're willing to undertake? Inspiration examples or are you looking for ideas?

Congrats on the new home!

I would also update the entry door and exterior lights and square up the garage door openings.

Good idea on the garage doors. Yeah I am a sucker for a bold modern door. That will be one of the first updates! Same with exterior lights- those easy fixes! Husband is a landscaper so making that a bit cleaned up too, not that it’s bad now. Thank you!!

Also I love the name :) my daughters middle name is Glo! My grandmothers name is GloAnn :)

Meghan Mattingly, I love that!

Is the round vent under the peak functional? Remove it, if you can. Maybe replace the siding on the porch with some stone and different skirting below the porch. Wrought iron rails will be a little less bulky. If you keep your shutters, take off the ones on the basement windows - they seem a little weird. (Be careful with black paint if your windows are vinyl.) Plus the other ideas.

I would go with modern white farmhouse look.