Meant to stay modern-ish. Somewhat modern 😀

You are going to put both above your island? That might be too much. i could see them in the same room if it was more of a beachy feel, or maybe farmhouse. but that wicker light would be out of place in a modern home.

Sorry, meant above the kitchen table

I’m trying to warm up the modern feel, but you are right maybe it’s too beachy

Show a picture of the space if you can.
Out of context I like the wicker one a lot!! Better than the glass.

I actually like the wicker one too, even if you're not trying to go "beachy" coastal, it's still a light that can fit with many different styles.