The natural was really yellow we didn’t like it! Natural on the top right

I second searching out a natural option that is less yellow and maintains something closer to the original wood tone. Beachy to me sounds so light and bright.

Misread coastal for beach. Sorry. Of these, I like #2.

I'm sorry, but I don't see the gray floor #2 working with City Loft.

Actually I don't see any of your stain choices playing well with City Loft. But I like the way the floor looks like with #1 (Pecan).

#2!

4

2❣️

I think light stains are great if you can pull them off. I just had my white oak floors refinished for the first time yesterday. These beautiful floors have been carpeted for 70 years! Special walnut is a nice light medium tone but I went with the slightly darker chestnut and water-based poly. I may move and this is a very neutral classic color. I definitely didn't want my floors looking like 1980s kitchen cabinets! For those who fear it will look plasticky, I can assure you it is a rich warm color.

@kempek01 you were right! We ended up finding a different color from the 4 I posted, fruitwood, which was exactly what we were looking for.

Can you please post a pic?