Software
Houzz Logo Print
risris

Is it feasible to change a ranch roofline?

13 years ago
last modified: 13 years ago
For starters - the pic attached is NOT my home, but is identical in shape and size. The roofline is just so strange - like a second roof is stacked on the first - yet very common in my area. I'm grateful for the porch entry it creates, but surely there are more beautiful ways to accomplish the same thing.

I love traditional cottages and farmhouses with well-proportioned forms and period trim. I love symmetry and elegance. I don't love faux-colonial ranches with perplexingly awkward rooflines.

So here's my question: the roof needs replacing soon. Can the middle section be chopped down and integrated into the main roof? It seems to me to just be cosmetic, but I have no idea.

I'd also love any ideas of what else could be done - adding a porch back on, adding some sort of articulation to the roof. Basically, can you make a ranch beautiful without tearing it down?

Thank you!

Comments (15)

  • 13 years ago
    Since it is not your house, I have nothing to go off of to estimate the probability of the type of construction that it is. You will need to go into your attic and take some pictures of the roof structure and post them here for any intelligent feedback. How much money do you want to spend? Some pictures of what you think it could look like would also be helpful.
  • 13 years ago
    HI -- Yes , Anything is possible if you throw enough money at it . Get an architect , it will be worth it . Check Houzz listings for your area .
  • 13 years ago
    The steel roof (at least that is what it looks like from the bad picture) is one reason for this roof line. What type of roofing do you intend to use?
  • 13 years ago
    It's not my house, but it's identical to my house (mine also brick) - I just don't have any good pics to post b/c my roofline is obscured by trees etc. Not able to take attic pics at the moment. I'm willing to spend 15-20K beyond the cost of the new roof, which should stretch because I live in a rural area and my father is a GC.
  • 13 years ago
    I'm considering architectural asphalt shingles or standing seam metal roofing (which I prefer but is much more $$$).
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I think the roof is doable...I'm more concerned about what happens to the brick on the gable ends...as the roof line changes it is either tearing down brick to a level line at the eaves or adding brick (and finding a color match) to match the new roof line. With your Dad a GC, I'd lean heavily on his local expertise and advice!
  • 13 years ago
    Is the picture you posted a house built by the same contractor in the same area? It is still a bit far off to see much on my phone. If your father is a GC, then have him explain the difference between a roof truss and a stick built roof. That will give you some good parameters of what you can do. That is what I was after with the pictures.
  • 13 years ago
    The cost of a metal roof can go up quickly when you add valleys to a roof.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    My guess is that you are going to be money ahead by adding to the roofs and not cutting into the roofs. It is a guess but I think you are going to find structural trusses and not rafters. (DON'T CUT TRUSSES WITHOUT THE TRUSS COMPANY'S ENGINEER'S BLESSING AND STAMP,) BTW: Adding much weight by using a heavier covering or adding more framing also needs to be looked at by the truss manufacturer but usually can be accomplished.
  • 13 years ago
    Following this because I have an awful ranch roofline and want to explore similar options.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Better that just a long flat roof (this is not a good look in my opinion)
    risris thanked Western Design International
  • 13 years ago
    Another detail you can do without tearing into the trusses is a hipped gable or jerkinhead detail on the ends of the house. Only go back to the first truss which is hopefully 2 feet back from the gable. Two feet plus the overhang would be enough to change the look a bit.
    risris thanked User
  • 13 years ago
    Thank you for the ideas, Western Design and Fred S! It's particularly helpful to see those roofline changes - I would have never thought of breaking the pitch, but it does make a difference!
  • 11 years ago
    I have this same roof, mine is stick built. I am thinking about a hip roof. Any thoughts on how it can be done or how it would look or if it is even an option.