Software
Houzz Logo Print
kelli_ga

Siding and gutter repairs - “How to”

5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago

I have some small exterior repair jobs to do. These are all interrelated which is why this post is so long.

Can anyone point me to some articles or give me advice on how to fix these problems?

(These jobs are not big enough for a knowledgable builder. I can’t even get a roofer to come out - still working on that.)

Background: The house is in a warm humid climate in the woods. The bottom floor is raised up with Piers footings and the crawl space is encapsulated. There is a brick skirt around the crawl space. No concrete slab or basement. Rain under the house does not seem to be an issue, especially now that the crawl space is encapsulated.

(1) GUTTERS: See gutter pic. I would like to replace the small sections of gutter on the house over the deck. There is a bay window area which creates odd angles. Current gutters are small and plastic. They are leaking in the corners over the deck, which causes water to pool toward the house. I would like to upgrade to larger rust-resistant gutters that will will withstand the weight of an extension ladder against them. I had those in a previous home - they were galvalume with metal braces. This job is not big enough for a gutter company as it is the only area of the house that needs gutters. (Houses around here generally don’t have gutters because tree debris always clogs them up, the houses are off the ground, there are lots of eaves, and the soil absorbs water quickly.)

  • Where can I buy sturdy gutter pieces and supplies?
  • How do I build and seal the odd angles of the gutter?
  • I’m not sure if there is flashing(?) How do I deal with that?

(2) SIDING OVER DECK: See siding pic. The siding has rotted, and the rot may be almost all the way through to the house. It has reached through to the interior subfloor under the door (left side of pic). The door threshold is loose. I will be replacing the door and threshold, but I need to fix the stuff underneath the door and above the deck. I need to fix the bottom row or two of siding and everything behind it that has rotted.

An inspector suggested cement siding for the bottom row to prevent future water damage, so I bought some hardi trim for the bottom row over the deck. I have not installed it yet.

  • What materials make up an exterior wall?
  • Which of these materials should I demo and replace?
  • Where do you buy wood siding like I have in the pic?
  • Can you point me to any articles that would tell me how to build this out?

(3) SUBFLOOR SECTION: A small piece of interior subfloor has rotted inside the house by the back door. The installer who encapsulated the crawl space told me to replace a full 4x8 section of the subfloor. (There was a language barrier so I may have misunderstood something.) Part of that area is under walls. I assume subfloor goes under studs, but I am not sure.

  • Do I really need to pull out a large section of subfloor, or can I just cut out the bad part and replace it, as long as I have joists or install blocking to support it?
  • Do I need to seal seams or do anything else? (I will be installing hardiebacker and 6x36” porcelain plank tiles over the subfloor)

(4) FRONT DOOR: I want to install a new, smaller front door. The current front door is 36” wide, with 12” sidelights on each side, opening inward. I will replace it with a 36” wide door opening outward. (It’s needed because we have very little space inside and there is a covered porch outside.) I would need to frame in the remaining 24”, then create more exterior wall to cover that 24” that was used by sidelights. I might move the porch light over too. Since I need to learn how to make an exterior wall anyway (see #2 above), I thought I could tackle this myself, or maybe with a door installer but they tend to not do framing.

  • Any tips on adding framing to the door to make the area smaller?
  • Any other tips on creating the exterior wall section?

(5) WINDOW TRIM: See gutter pic. An example of rotted window trim is above the gutters. The trim is white. Multiple windows need trim replaced, usually on the bottom. I assume I need to dig the old trim out, clean somehow, and put new trim in with some kind of sealant or caulk. Is there more to it?

  • Where can I find more info on how to replace window trim properly?
  • What trim material should I buy?

These are all small jobs even though the post is long. I’m not confident I can find someone who will come out here and do it all properly, and I would love to know how to do it myself and save the $ to pay a roofer. Please post any tips below. Thanks!

Gutter and window pic:


Siding and back door pic:



Just FYI: The decking is 2x6 planks which have held up extraordinally well. Only the one in the pic is a candidate for replacement. The deck is ugly but solid. I will be pressure-washing, staining and sealing it after everything is repaired.

Also, the roof does not leak - It is just due for replacement or needs preventative repairs. I prefer to replace, but I need to get these repairs done before the roof is replaced. I need to do these repairs to proceed with floor tile and kitchen remodel which are happening soon.

Comments (3)

  • 5 years ago

    Did you just buy this house? Is it gping to be a flip? Arr you are more concerned with fixing the cosmetic aspects here or in figuring out and solving the root of these problems?


    What I would do:


    1. The biggest problem here as far as I can tell is that you have no downspout. Basically, your gutters are collecting water from the roof roof then it has nowhere to go. Eventually it fills up and spills over. If you don't want that to happen, you need to find a way to connect the gutters together and then install a downspout that will take the water away from your house. Be sure you get the water away from your house or you will just be moving the problem rather than solving it. Whatever you do with the gutters, you need to give the water somewhere to go.


    2 and 3. This is not a diy except for the most experienced diy folks. You don't even know if you will have to replace structural elements beyond the subfloor. Be prepared that when you hire someone, the damage may be more extensive and require more repairs than you can tell right now. If there are rotted studs and rotted subfloor, chances are that there is also rotted sill plates and rotted floor joists. Before you can remove even partial structural elements, you need to have temporary support in place.


    Your problem is not so much the siding material so much that it doesn't seem like you have any flashing between the house and the deck. Changing to hardiboard won't solve that. You need to fix the rot, then waterproof correctly, then replace the siding and door.


    I'm guessing there probably wasn't adequate flashing around the door either. Fix that before you replace the door and trim.


    4. I would not bother with this at this point if it is mostly aesthetics. Sure, it has some function issues, but you have far bigger fish to fry! When you have fixed the other stuff, you can hire someone to replace the door. A reputable company should have a carpenter who know framing an finish work to complete this job. It's not just a door repacment because you will have insulation, drywall, siding work (which will involve weaving the old siding into the new). Or you could replace the door with a new door the same size that just swings out.


    5. Lack of flashing/inadequate flashing may also be a problem around your window trim and there may be more water damage than just the bottom trim. Were the windows replaced at some point? Some unprofessional window replacement companies just slap the new windows in without any kind of nailing flange or flashing or waterproofing. You find out later when the windows leak or rot. Inspecting all of your windows is probably a good idea.


    I hope some other folks will pop in to give their opinions. I do think you can and should find someone to address the rot issues you have. They do not seem to be purely cosmetic and it could be a much larger job than you are thinking which would make someone willing to do it. (Also, be prepared that they will not be able to give you a fixed price. Too much unknown here. You will probably need a cost plus contract because contractors will have no idea how much it will cost to fix until they open it up and see how much damage is actually there.)

    kelli_ga thanked K B
  • 5 years ago

    You might have a "handyman" company or one that specializes in exterior work - that can handle new roof and all the needed repairs. Be sure it isn't one that mostly focuses on selling and installing siding - you want one with experience in dealing with rot and structural repair.

    Most roofers can install gutters (around here, at least, they do). The lack of a downspout immediately caught my eye, made me wonder why the gutters were even installed.

    Unless you are in a very rural area with few workmen, with the potential work here as K B has explained, you should be able to find someone to take on all the needed work as one job.

    Good luck!

    PS you can order gutters and all the accessories online, or buy them at nearly any hardware store, or some lumber yards, or find out where the siding/roofing companies get their materials - some will also sell to retail customers like you.

    kelli_ga thanked raee_gw zone 5b-6a Ohio
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    A few answers first:

    Yes, I just bought the house as a fixer. Yes, I plan to live in it for many years.

    The pics I posted are the worst of the siding. Most of the siding is in good shape but needs to be sealed.

    Regarding crawl space:

    Two inspectors saw the dirt floor crawl space before I bought the house. The only significant comment on the health of the crawl space was that a vapor barrier and ventilation were required. The vents were closed at the time. I opened them shortly after moving into the house. An inspector also mentioned the subfloor and wood problems near the back door.

    Recently, an encapsulation specialist evaluated the crawl space and I bought his system. The two installers seemed pretty experienced. They were under there installing the vapor barrier, sealing the vents and installing the dehumidifier. An electrician was down there as well connecting the dehumidifier. The only issue the lead installer mentioned was the subfloor near the back door. The sales guy came back a week later to check out the work. These guys came highly recommended. With the exception of the subfloor near the door, they said the crawl space and structure were in good shape as far as they could tell, as long as I addressed the humidity issue to prevent wood deterioration.

    I went into the crawl space for the first time today. The wood and structure overall looked ok to me and there were a lot of support blocks. I bought a moisture meter and I will pin-check the wood and test for solidity before I start the tile. I felt pretty good about what I saw.

    So I think enough people have seen the underside of the house for me to feel confident in it.

    When I moved into the house, the carpet felt slightly damp, like it had been shampooed but it did not look clean. I removed all carpet and foam, and exposed the subfloor. I was surprised that it was in such good shape and it seemed solid.

    Regarding the siding:

    It makes sense to me that this is the only area affected because rainwater pools and splashes on the deck. The gutter on the right is not capped and water pours out of it. The gutters are flimsy. The rest of the house is elevated and the rain just goes off the roof and into the ground. Often I do not know when it is raining because the rain does not make enough sound. The roof is steep and there is no hardscape visible from the windows.

    I did make an appointment today to have a roofer come evaluate next week. We’ll see if he shows up and bids on the job. It makes sense that the water problem is related to lack of flashing because I believe the gutters were added as an afterthought after the roof was complete.

    I don’t think the windows have been replaced.

    I think the downspout is in the yard. I’m not sure what the original gutter installation was supposed to be.

    Thank you so much for the helpful comments!

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals