I would vote for Iron Ore, because it's a better match to the dark tones in your brick and contrasts nicely with your shiny black door BUT I would also REMOVE the shutters on the two large upper windows because shutters are supposed to look as though they could close over the windows they are attached to, and these clearly don't, so they just look like pasted-on decorations.

I voted black — I prefer the bit of contrast and stronger presence it brings. But I honestly like them both and think either would look nice. :)

Thanks all! I am leaning towards the black now. Now I do have 3 other samples in addition to the black magic. See them here. Top left is BM Soot (blue undertone) / top right is Black Magic (slight warmth) / bottom left is Tricorn Black (more true black) / bottom right is BM Black (similar to Tricorn). What would be your choice?

and here is a picture in the sun next to the roof. Top left is Black magic. Top right is Tricorn black. Bottom is Iron Ore

Iron Ore based on your sun photo. The top left and right just look like shiny black plastic...?

I like the Iron Ore because the darker black has too much contrast for so many shutters. It also allows you to use a darker black on your front door for contrast.

Sorry but hardly any of those windows should even have shutters definately not the doubl ones and IMO the house looks cluttered with all those shutters If you want to put them on the single windows then the Iron Ore

As stated in two comments, your windows do not need shutters.Save yourself time and money and remove them. However, I strongly recommend that you change your landscaping so that you allow your shrubs to grow into their natural shapes

Thanks guys. Does anyone have any examples of what it would look like without shutters?