Software
Houzz Logo Print
angelapm0

What to do with this fireplace??

5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago

Looking for suggestions on this very 90s fireplace. The first thing i want to change is the tile. I thought about painting it, but it’s a working fireplace (not gas) and the tile above gets very, very hot. High heat paint is very limited in colors, and it’s not really meant for time.

So…I need to replace the tile…but with what?

Then, do I paint the brick??

The colors of the living room are cool…greys, blues.

Any ideas are much appreciated!!


Comments (17)

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Can you take a picture from further back?

    I actually like the brick. I would remove the tile and do some nice pieces of slate. Something like a Brazilian gray or black slate - solid piece - not tiles.

    If there is a way to make the brick mortar a little darker, that would be great too!

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Thanks! Here’s a photo from further back (we’re replacing the mirror and figuring out the sconce situation).


  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Nice! I still think doing solid pieces ( cut to fit ) of slate or marble for the hearth and the piece above the firebox would be great!

    I still like the brick but I think I would consider painting the mantle and the bit of trim on the sides so they create a nicer frame since right now they blend into the wall

  • 5 years ago

    I'd even replace the brick. What about a splitface marble.



  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    If you paint that tile, it's going to resemble this.


    Just, NO.

    Remove everything and do a marble or some other stone surround. (or wait, I have a suggestion for your existing brick later)

    marble

    basalt

    granite

    quartzite

    even a porcelain large slab tile,

    All will withstand heat. (just make sure you have the proper underlying substrate that is code approved)



    You could probably chip off all of the tile and brick off of yours and redo it with whatever you like.

    This is that split faced quartz ledger stone with a traditional white mantle surround. On the hearth looks like a similar color marble to match the quartz tile.

    for me, this is a little blah. I think there are better options.



    If you give me an idea of what you like, and the style you want, I could show you diff ideas.

    #1, cheapest idea.

    Get some similar brick (same size and texture) and fill in the top portion. (I photoshopped it here so you can see)


    Now, Paint it. white, black, gray, whatever you like.

    get a nice wood beam mantle for the top of the brick.

    Paint any gold around the opening black.

    For the hearth, find a large basalt tile and install it inside the wood molding (you could get a mosaic basalt tile and do the same)

    Viola' !

    Here's how the brick would look white w/the same upper decor. (I know! looking good! the decor items really make or break the entire look)

    For the hearth, this is a white marble w/a rough cut edge. you could omit your wood trim and get a thick rough cut piece of stone.



    Example, #3 get some marble cut to go around the opening, frame around it w/a material (depending on your code requirements) wood, or cement overlay, etc. top it with a nice wood mantle


    this one has the stone tile around the 'heat zone', and a more traditional MDF mantle around the stone. get your sconces and art. for your hearth, do a solid piece of marble that matches


    you could do a marble mosaic tile around the opening, and go traditional w/the mantle, or go more modern. up to you

    if you like tile, then do a cement tile

    Here's that picture I photoshopped onto your fireplace. Becki Owens design.


    there are a million tile choices. this hearth is marble or a quartz. white oak mantle beam.


    see the marble hearth? you could find a remnant for cheap, and set it in the floor inside that wood molding you have.


    You want to upgrade the look a bit?


    you could do a smoothed cement overlay (over cement board) or you could do it right over the brick, and paint it white. Above the natural wood mantle, do some wood trim-work design and paint it black. you have space for sconces, and I think this would look awesome w/a more modern sconce.

    a Roman Clay application would be similar:.


    million choices for a porcelain or ceramic tile mosaic. this is a black chevron surround w/white mantle and tongue/groove accenting above the mantle.


    I love this one. Zellige tile and white oak mantle beam.


    zellige tile in a subway shape. this is done on the raised hearth w/no wood trim around the base. you could take this all the way up, or stop like the above picture and add a wood mantle.


    sorry for all the photos! there are just so many options available to you, I want you to see what all you have the ability to do!

    (edit, sorry housegal, those pictures you're showing look nothing like the tile / brick OP currently has. adding art above it isn't going to make it look like your photos. The tile has to go)

  • 5 years ago

    Visit a stone fabricator for ideas and ask if they have a piece of slate you could take home to see how it would go with the brick’s mortar. If you like it, they can measure, cut and install it. It would be a great improvement.

  • 5 years ago

    Since you have the gray thing going on, in contrast to the warm floors, fireplace tile, start to add touches of warm wood accents to your cool choices as in photo below. This will warm up the room and tie together your current "givens:" fireplace, floors. Here's a room with gray furniture warmed up by fireplace, pendant, coffee table, cabinet, art work.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Seeing door of shapes, I like similar types of fp shapes. Beth's dark hearth is fine, with black firebox there. Then add your color accessories. I like what you have now, basically.

    Kings Raku Ceramic Wall Tile, Cream · More Info


  • 5 years ago

    Very 'specific' look but -- if brick were painted light --


    Mosaic Artwork, Lone Bloom, 12"x12" · More Info


    Mosaic Wall Art, Blue Tulip, 10"x10" · More Info


  • 5 years ago

    Nothing wrong in blending with your amber floor -


    Mosaic Patterns, Ochre Sunflower, 20"x20" · More Info


  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    8 x 35"

    Wall Art Mosaic, Water Lily, 12"x12" · More Info



  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Design plan goes for sconces too... what does the rest of you house look like? are there more modern touches like the door?

  • 5 years ago

    What style are you going for? I see a peek of your front door and if it's original, looks like you have a MCM house which would be in keeping with the stacked brick pattern of your fireplace. Is MCM your style? IMO the current tile and hearth were added later. Maybe there is something interesting underneath it or maybe not. The tile is the weak point of the fireplace. I like the idea of a basalt look tile but not sure that's your style.

    Long way to say, decide what your style is and then decide on what to do with the fireplace. Once you paint or remove that brick, it's gone. The tile definitely isn't helping you. I don't see any fireplaces in your ideabooks so can't really offer advice to your taste yet.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Please, please show much more of the room. We're all showing very different styles for your fireplace, but someone pointed out your great midcentry door, which is so great. That truly effects all kinds of choices. The lines of your furniture look pretty modern, but we can't really see them. Beth H's #1 and #2 fireplace suggestions--plain white, round mirror, plain wood mantel would look best in a modern setting. Here are some sconces in a modern style. The finish should match other metal finishes in the room, which we can't really see. Good design takes in an entire space, not just one feature.



    I would totally paint the inside of your door--maybe a mustard color that would go with your gray and blue.

    Does this style appeal to you?

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Okay, maybe I overdid it with the black pearl leather slate...