Software
Houzz Logo Print
missytitus

Kitchen passthrough with doors?

4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago

Hi,

We are starting the process of remodeling our kitchen. I'm torn between having it more closed off from the living/dining area and having it more open.

Closed off

Pros:

- more cabinet space

- guests are shielded from kitchen messiness

- more wall space on the opposite side for furniture/art

Cons:

- someone cooking is cut off from guests

Open

Pros:

- someone cooking can be in conversation with guests

- more light can flow through into pretty dark living area

- can create a "serving shelf" on the passthrough

Cons:

- kitchen mess on full display

- possible cost of opening this load bearing wall

- possibly weird to have an opening next to a slightly different opening (into bar, with a wood header)

Here are some sketch mock-ups (by me) that I hope can illustrate what the options I'm talking about:




So finally my question! Is there a (attractive) way to "close" a passthrough so we can have the best of both worlds? Like sliding panels or something? Does anyone have photo examples of something like this?

Comments (8)

  • 4 years ago

    This layout makes no sense. None of the working room is in the rights spots. Post what exists now, in a back and white diagram with measurements. Renders are counter productive until the very end of the design phase.

  • 4 years ago


    Traditional kitchen with a pantry · More Info


    Andover, MA · More Info


    Hobby Farm Kitchen · More Info


    Traditional Kitchen Remodel in Tualatin Oregon · More Info


    Melissa Titus thanked Tara
  • 4 years ago

    Not a pro, but if the pass through is at the bottom of the second rendering, is it over a sink or is that a stove? If stove, wouldn't a hood be there anyway? I guess I also don't understand why the bar area is U shaped with two seats facing away from the kitchen (must be walked around to enter bar area) instead of just having an L shaped bar area. Especially if those two seats are in a pathway/doorway which could impact flow of traffic from the room south of the drawing.

    My sister has a pass through in her 80s condo and she basically ignores it. Nothing is ever passed through and no conversation occurs from kitcen to the adjacent dining area. I can't imagine opening a load bearing wall for something that seems kind of retro/dated. I worked in a condo community of 88 homes (built in the 80-90s) and some condos had pass throughs, but when renovations were done, most people opted to remove them entirely. I never saw anyone that had windows or shutters in the pass through space.

    Melissa Titus thanked tlynn1960
  • 4 years ago

    My moher’s house, built in the 60’s had something like you describe It looked a lot like Tara’s first picture and had a bar with bifold solid shutters hung on either side that could be closed. The problem was that the bar was a space where lots of stuff collected and so it would have been a major pain to ever close them.

    Melissa Titus thanked bacino
  • 4 years ago

    This is attempt #3. I get a post nearly completed and Houzz tells me something went wrong and erases everything I wrote and posted. This time I am going to try to get the photos in first and then put in the text.


    Ideas I found for a similar situation.


    Madison Park Traditional · More Info


    (45) Pinterest · More Info




    (15) Pinterest · More Info



    Because I am getting fed up with what I have written being erased and errored out, I am going to try to post this and then make a new post of what I am doing.







    Melissa Titus thanked julieste
  • PRO
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I need to see your space as it is and a to scale 2D floor plan showing all windows doorways where the doorways lead and all measurements clearly marked . IMO pass throughs work only in really warm climates and they open to a lanai or deck for summer entertaining .BTW I never like kichens open to LRS only DRs Please do not start a new post there is nothing worse than a duplicate post .

  • 4 years ago

    My house has a very small pass-through (original to the 1910 house) that slides up vertically into a pocket in the wall, like opening a single-hung window (it opens to the back of the dining room hutch, between the drawer section and the shelf section). Unless you have very high ceilings, this approach would significantly limit the vertical height of the pass-through.