Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_26131579

Why do engineered wood samples look SO different from end product?

4 years ago

I have been searching for higher quality white oak wide plank engineered hardwood floors for some time. I have looked at many samples. Several times I have then purchased a sample box to compare the end product/floors with what i saw on a large sample. Each time lately, I have found that the floors are not even close and have up to 50% of boards with defect, etc.


Could this be happening due to changing quality control issues?


I am now looking at ordering wide plank real hardwood floors instead from a local hardwood company, and having either prefinished at their local facility or finished on site.

Comments (26)

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    I think there is a tendency to display the prettiest boards (which makes no sense, the sample should be representative) there is also a trend at least in my region of the market liking more rustic varieties (but still the sample should reflect that). I’m sure supply issues are playing a part too. It stinks.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Sample boards are often several years old, made when supplies were different. As @HALLETT & Co. says, they often have prettiest boards, not typical boards.

    There are different grades of hardwood, too, of course. If you choose the local company, ask them to show you various grades of the same wood.

    User thanked apple_pie_order
  • 4 years ago

    I would always opt for solid hardwood finished on site. No contest. If that’s doable for you, then do it!

    User thanked lynzy1
  • 4 years ago

    They arent ”radically” different different. Wood varies. A lot. There’s a lot of different trees that go into a single floor. Homeowners have a hard time imagining how much that variation translates to the large scale vs the small scale. This is why getting the help of a designer to pull it all together can be ao important. Someone needs to have the knowledge of the big picture.

    User thanked User
  • 4 years ago

    @User I completely understand where you are coming from. I should have been more specific - one sample finish was a beautiful light nutmeg color - but the updated wood they are now producing is such a pinky tone - it almost looks like someone stained it with a bit of koolaid. Another sample was a similar pretty nutmeg, with zero stripes (sapwood) when we ordered a box 70% of the planks were sapwood. The floor looked more like a beech look with the heavy stripes. I had even went out of my way to look at three sample boards at various places. I loved the knots and unique look of the floors and the natural feel of the wood. I just was hoping that the actual products would be somewhat close in consistancy.

  • 4 years ago

    @HALLETT & Co. I honestly am thinking it is due to supply issues at this point. The products consistently have been so different from photos online + any samples ive seen. I love the natural and unique look of rustic floors, but would love for the stain to be similar to what is shown on sample boards. I am likely going to have custom wide plank floors installed, its a safer bet.

  • 4 years ago

    I had the same problem. I had to buy many extra boxes and hand pick the boards. I would have done solid finished on site if we weren't on slab.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    What brands are you looking at?

    What do you consider higher quality?

    My 2 finalists, Duchateau and Legno Bastone, I would consider mid+ level quality ... but I am picky!

    This company I'm linking had beautiful product and I would call them high-level quality, but you will pay quite a bit more. I was very tempted by their products, but it was not worth the extra cost for the market we are building in. https://northernwideplank.com/

  • 4 years ago

    Thank you @chispa


    My supplier did the same for me, held stock of the floors I ordered sample boxes of. I wish I had a good experience with quality, too!


    The main brand I have been looking at is Hallmark Flooring. This is the top engineered hardwood in my area. (I do not live on the West Coast)


    May I ask what the price per square foot is of those brands you mentioned? I may have to look into them!

  • 4 years ago

    @Shasta It is so frustrating, isn’t it? What brands were you looking at?

  • 4 years ago

    Same thing happened to us January 2021. Our floor guy didn't order enough wood and they ran out before they finished our floors. And when I say they ran out, I mean there was NONE to be found. We had to wait for more to be made and then shipped. The new shipment finally came at the end of April. What showed up wasn't even close to what they put down in January even though it was the same stuff. Luckily, the room it was going in was the main bedroom and didn't butt up to any of the other wood. The new stuff was pretty ugly so I ended up covering most of it up with an area rug. As far as samples, you're right, the sample we looked at prior to installation in January didn't look anything like what showed up to put down. Frustrating.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I don't live on the west coast either, but I used to. The Florida wood floor showrooms had the same brands that I saw on the west coast, but you have to go to many showrooms, because not every store has every brand. Some brands are in every showroom and some brands are more "exclusive" and more picky of who gets to distribute/sell their product.

    The list prices at the stores varied from $8-13 for the same product (note: pricing from a year ago). With better pricing for larger quantities and, of course, contractor pricing. You need to shop around and also know what the installation costs will be. Ideally the store that sells you the floor will also do the installation. This is important because if your floor fails for whatever reason, you want that one entity to point your finger to, instead of them pointing at each other for who is to blame.

  • 4 years ago

    @chispa Thanks I have been looking for a long time and Reward and Hallmark were the best quality that I could find in my city - I have gone to the best suppliers - and they didnt match current samples. The contractor pricing I received is around $10-11 / sq foot. Retail is closer to $13-14 / sq foot. They are supposed to be higher quality. But, the color is not consistent.

  • 4 years ago

    @kpyeatt Wow I’m sorry you had to go through such an ordeal. What brand were the floors? I am so afraid of the same thing.. as we are going to renovate our bedrooms next year once we finish the rest of our remodel.


    It’s unbelieveable that companies can get away with the varying colors and stains.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    kpyeatt's problem was due to her contractor not ordering enough wood. There is no guarantee that different lots will match ... too many variables.

    It is the same with fabrics and wallpaper. Quartz counters too. The raw materials change and the dyes/pigments also change, specially if they are natural products and sourced from several locations. You never order expensive bolts of fabric without getting a CFA, a cutting for approval, from the current lot.

    Even if you order a man made product like LVP, you still need to order from the same lot. Raw materials, dyes and process are not 100% and you will get variations between lots.

  • 4 years ago

    chispa - exactly. Different lot numbers. BUT, between January and April, they also changed the way the wood fit together. The new wood would not even join with the "old" January wood if we had needed to do that. So even the installation process was different. The whole problem was the contractor. If he had done his job correctly, we wouldn't have had the problem that we did.

  • 4 years ago

    @chispa, can I ask which floor you ended up going with? and do you have pictures? I am also torn between both Duchateau and Legno Bastone!!

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    @kgiryes, I went with the Duchateau because it had the look and color I wanted. They have some character and texture, which I hope will help hide some of the scratches the 3 dogs will cause.

    I felt the Legno Bastone quality was one notch better, but the color wasn't quite right for me. The LB also had longer boards and in the box I got, even the long boards were dead straight and flat. Legno Bastone was a bit more expensive.

    Don't have any really good photos without dust or paper covering the floor, but this one should give you an idea.

    Duchateau:


  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Even though the product says "engineered" it's still using actual wood on the top of the composite flooring. And natural materials vary in look and in hue, be it wood, stone, or anything else occurring in nature. You can't expect your samples to be an exact match to the product you end up with. Always best to get as many samples of the same product as you can so you can see the variation and come to terms with it.

  • 4 years ago

    @chispa Gorgeous!!! Thanks :)

  • 4 years ago

    @chispa, what color Duchateau is this? I have been considering Riverstone Lys but it’s just seems a little more gray than I want. This color you’ve chosen is very beautiful.

  • 4 years ago

    @chispa Your flooring is beautiful!

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    You have to wonder where the raw logs originate from with those mass producers that could create issues as well.


    Interesting tidbit from Wikipedia on Hickory as an example.


    Hickory is a common name for trees composing the genus Carya, which includes around 18 species.[2] Five or six species are native to China, Indochina, and India (Assam), as many as twelve are native to the United States, four are found in Mexico, and two to four are native to Canada.[3][4]


    "BUT, between January and April, they also changed the way the wood fit together."


    Could have been caused by using a different Asian mill. Perhaps one was shut down, idled or moved production to a different country. These mass producers/middlemen don't want to run out of available flooring to sell.

  • 3 years ago

    So interesting you mentioned Hallmark flooring. Was your Hallmark flooring ordered from cambodia or local? I am confused because I thought it was a local conpany in Nebraska, and they said they have them in stock… but the supplier I bought them from (NFM), ordered them from cambodia andnit took like a month to get. They don’t match the sample at all. we ordered the woodhoise Cherry Creek but it’s missing the Cherry and has a more yellow undertone. What is the point of looking st so many samples if they don’t match?

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    "What is the point of looking st so many samples if they don’t match?"

    Thanks for asking this question!

    In past few years flooring professionals and homeowners are struggling with color issues big time. When hottest-selling European White Oak floors have been mostly in lighter than natural color, same finishing tech and color formular applied on a different batch of oak could turn out to have different hues and tones. In many cases, factories had hard time to duplicate the sample board colors in showrooms across the country. The following factors play important roles:

    1. how long the sample boards been made? aged?

    2. how complex the wood color was achieved? smoked, reactive stains.

    3. wood species, Brazilian Cherry is notorious for color changing with sun.

    4. change of lumber sourcing origin, oak from France to other EU countries.

    5. who you purchase your wood floor from and installation? An experienced wood floor professional can walk you through the process and set your expectation correctly at the time of decision making. So, no surprises. In case anything unexpected happens, they know how to correct it.

    Hope my experience can help people who look to replace their floors with wood, solid or engineered.

    As Hallmark Floors Spotlight dealer, I am quite familiar with all their collections. As far as I know, they made majority of their products in Cambodia. They are actually one of the better brands which has managed their floor colors and quality with consistency.