Software
Houzz Logo Print
tara_goodin

Plaster ceiling help needed

4 years ago

Bought a new house and are remodeling the kitchen, it has 8ft tall ceilings and a soffit in the kitchen that made it feel much smaller than it is. It's a 1950s home with button board plaster walls and ceiling. We removed the soffit and found that in one section it was installed after the wall and ceiling plaster, but the majority was installed before. We now have the issue of the ceiling edge being attached to a 2x4 that hangs lower than the ceiling height. The original plan was to add drywall to the ceiling and wall areas where the soffit were. We are not planning on replacing the upper cabinets in some of the areas so covering up the difference with cabinets is out.
My question is, would it be possible to cut the plaster and metal corner mesh away from the edge 2x4s so they can be removed and we can continue with the original plan of adding drywall to the ceiling? Or would this compromise the integrity of the ceiling plaster too much? I'm trying to preserve the plaster and do not want to remove and replace the entire ceiling. If removing the 2x4s isn't an option, any creative ideas for working around this?
Pictures attached to help with visualization. Thank you in advance for your advice.

Comments (3)

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    the 2 x 4 can easily be removed, it was used to hold up the soffit. To avoid damage to the existing plaster use a reciprocating saw with metal/wood blade and cut the nails, and board into pieces if needed. It doesn't hold anything up now.

    Just a tip, measure the 2 x 4's in the wall and write it down for reference. 2x4's in the past were bigger than now and makes a difference when buying windows and doors. Today they're 1 1/2" thick by 3 1/2 wide. Originally they were actually 2" thick by 4" wide and later reduced in size to 3 3/4" wide. Measure your total plaster thickness and you'll find it's 3/4" thick so 1/2" thick sheet rock is to thin and must be built up to match the existing plaster.

    Also the exterior sheathing ,may be 3/4" boards compared to 7/16" sheathing today.

    All these little changes in dimensions should be noted to save yourself a lot of trouble it you decide to buy doors or windows.

  • 4 years ago

    @Kevin, thanks so much for your reply. I figured removing the rest of the soffit could be done but it's nice to hear confirmation I won't destroy the ceiling by doing so! 

    Really appreciate your tips about measuring studs and sheeting while the wall is open. That's great advice and I'll be sure to make good notes on that.

  • 4 years ago

    I would consider gutting the entire kitchen. You'll end up with a far better result, as by the time you rewire and upgrade the plumbing you might be patching more than you hoped for. You will also be able to fix any framing issues (that ceiling looks like it sags 2" over 2'), insulate, and fix many other issues that can crop up. Every subcontractor on the job will be happier too as their job will be much easier. Drywall is one of the cheapest phases of a kitchen remodel, most times it's not cost effective to save old ceilings and walls.