Software
Houzz Logo Print
bobtownsuz

Bathroom remodel - unrealistic timeline?

4 years ago

I have a tiny 4'x8' bathroom to be completely renovated. Have had 7 different GC look at it, some gave very detailed quotes, one sent me a text message with a price and no detail (really!), one never got back to me. The one I am leaning toward is a certified tile installer who works with a plumber; a nephew does the painting; and he has someone else come in and do the shower door after all work is done (it will likely be a custom door.)

The current shower is made of corian walls and a shower pan; the floor tile will have to be removed and the original 1950s pink wall tile has to go. We are retiling floor (but not bathroom walls), tiling shower floor and walls. Drywall will have to be installed halfway up the wall where the square pink tile will be taken off. Above the pink tile is original plaster wall.

The quote for the job specifies "Install Schluter waterproof shower system with a 3x4 pan and brushed nickel drain. Install 12x 20 niche on wall opposite diverter if possible (or will be installed on back wall) Install customer supplied tile to shower walls and pan" and "Apply TL1000 floor leveler to bath floor and install customer supplied tile" along with specifications for demo, reinstalling toilet, installing new sink & light, reinstalling existing medicine cabinet.

The CTI says they can do this bathroom in 1.5 weeks. Does this sound realistic? I have seen many pictures on his Facebook page of work he has done and it looks really beautiful. Or should I be suspicious of him as a GC because of an unrealistic timeline? His FB page shows that he has done full bathroom and kitchen renovations, not just the tile work.

Comments (20)

  • 4 years ago

    That sounds like a fast timeline to me as you don’t know what you’ll find when opening up the existing walls. Our bathroom total guy remodel took 4 weeks (we moved plumbing too).

    Ask for a couple of references and call them.

  • 4 years ago

    It depends, a fast turn around may be one of his specialties. We lived in a condo with one bathroom and there is a contractor here who does only bathrooms and only condos and gets them one in one week and leaves you without a toilet for only one day usually. But everything must be onsite for him to start and he has subs scheduled like clockwork sometimes multiple different sorts of subs in and out on the same day for several days. He has it down to a science.

    On the flip side I have had a bathroom take several months.

    bobtownsuz thanked palimpsest
  • 4 years ago

    If everything is on site before beginnng, and he only works on 1 project at a time, with great responsive subcontractor relationships, and employees, then a 4 day bath is possible for a tiny bath. If theres no inspections required, or problems. Which would not be the norm.

  • 4 years ago

    I don't see how this could occur.


    How do they do the 24 hour flood test? In my location bathrooms need to be inspected and the inspectors are busy and don't show up when scheduled.


    I have heard of places that do a fast turnaround but I think they use a prefab floor and shower installation because there requires a certain amount of time to stuff to dry and cure. I also can't imagine that a tilesetter would be able to do a careful job on that type of schedule. Many tiles have to be culled through in order to get pleasing layout - particularly if they are marble or marble look tiles.


    I understand if one has only one bathroom and therefore absolutely needs a functional bathroom done as quickly as possible but I think most people figure out a way to work around it because they are more interested in a better result. You can have a functioning toilet while other work is being done - people shower at the gym or rely on the kindness of friends or neighbors for example.

    bobtownsuz thanked Helen
  • PRO
    4 years ago

    "Or should I be suspicious of him as a GC because of an unrealistic timeline?"


    No. He knows how long this takes.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Depends what you are looking for. First off, please do not call him a GC unless he has the proper insurance and is licensed in your area he is not a GC. I agree with Helen that there should be a flood test. Are you installing new shower valves? This needs to be inspected. Are you pulling permits? I don't care about facebook pictures, get references!


    On the flip side, maybe he works 10 hour days and weekends and has a great process? This is still very optimistic timing. We are typically a 3 week timeframe for a bathroom remodel as you described.


    Oh yes, custom shower doors don't get measured until tile is complete. So... you may be able to shower after 2 weeks but I will bet dollars to donuts you won't have a shower door.

    bobtownsuz thanked Top Drawer Carpentry LLC
  • 4 years ago

    I agree with what Top Drawer said about the glass portion. You could realistically have all else done if choreographed to perfection and all items on site prior to start.

    bobtownsuz thanked thinkdesignlive
  • 4 years ago

    We do have toilet, pedestal sink, shower system, tile, paint already purchased. Medicine cabinet being reused & new light fixture to be purchased. Exhaust fan was recently installed (previously none.) The contractor did say door would be after everything was done & we would have to use shower curtain for awhile till it was installed.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    THe other thing that nobody mentioned so far (including in your statement of work) is the necessary inspections (if applicable). Nowdays in my town I could be waiting several days for the plumbing inspector to come before I can close up that wall. That could easily eat up half your week


    ETA: oops i see @Top Drawer Carpentry LLC mentioned this

    bobtownsuz thanked thisisnotadrill
  • 4 years ago

    Tbh, I expect it to take longer, if only because of waiting for inspection as you say. I’m just trying to figure out how/if I can trust this guy. I already laughed away one contractor whose “quote” was a text message with an exorbitant price & no info other than his bottom line, and another who wanted to do the job sans permits or licensed & insured electricians & plumbers because, you know, that just takes time and costs money.

  • 4 years ago

    Not to mention the other two contractors who wanted me to get my materials from their (1) fell off the truck/cheap material suppliers or (2) their “exclusive” overpriced suppliers.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    1.Certificate of insurance

    2. References you can contact

    3. Insurance for subs

    4. Apples to apples written proposal

    5. Proposal needs to have payment structure. You shouldn't pay more than 20% deposit

    6. Licensed either current or gets licensed prior to signing agreement

    If he cant provide these, move on.

    I'm guessing you want to trust this gentleman because he gave you an appealing price?

    bobtownsuz thanked Top Drawer Carpentry LLC
  • 4 years ago

    Feels a bit fast. We are in the middle of a bathroom remodel. Bigger project than yours and in larger space, and we are looking at minimum of 6 weeks and realistically 8 due to unexpected labor delays. We are starting the main shower work tomorrow. The timeline right now is to have shower pan built, tested, and inspected by the end of this week. Tile starts next week and the current estimate is 2 weeks to install 235 square feet of total tile comprised of flooring, shower walls, and a tile wainscot on other walls.

    bobtownsuz thanked rjknsf
  • 4 years ago

    I have asked him for proof of license and insurance and for references I can talk to. I do not give trust based on price - I have been through a lot of renovations (and contractors) on our previous house, including complete redo of our kitchen (where I had to fire a designer and contractor at point of delivery of cabinets, because designer completely stopped working on the project and the contractor threatened me personally) and a complete tear down and rebuild of a two car garage that was built into the side of a hill and for which I had to have a structural engineer develop the design for proper structural integrity and drainage (that project went great!)

    I know that low bid is not the way to choose a contractor.

    The contractor who did my previous kitchen is retired; another we worked with was going to do our bathroom but lost his two employees and can't find new help, he is only taking small jobs now. I have a good idea what the job should reasonably cost from that contractor, who I trust. Another contractor gave us an exorbitant quote, a third wanted us to buy shoddy materials from his "preferred supplier." A fourth got covid and then long covid after we talked with him about the job and were ready to go ahead. A fifth spent an hour discussing the project with us and then never submitted a bid. #6 sent us the text message "quote" with a high price and no details, #7 is the certified tile installer with what I think is an unrealistic timeline but who seems to do good tile work and who I hope will give me good references and show me proof of insurance; his bid is higher but not extremely higher than my trusted contractor who can't do the job. #8 was the contractor who says he works without permits and without insurance or licenses to "save money and time." All these contractors were obtained through referrals from neighbors, our realtor, or neighborhood Facebook recommendation groups (which is discouraging, if this is the quality of contractor such referrals produce.)


    I have been trying to hire a contractor since last August and I admit I am at the point of exhaustion but I don't want to make a mistake with #7 the certified tile installer and hire him out of despair/exhaustion. I'm trying my best to vet him. If references are good and the licenses and insurance are in line, is his proposed timeline enough of a concern to take a pass on him?


    FYI for the tile work, the shower walls are approx 72 sq ft, shower floor + bathroom floor altogether is 32 sq ft and there will be no tile on the bathroom walls, only paint, so a total of 104 sq ft surface to be tiled (plus shower niche to be created.)

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    I would say you are doing your due diligence.  I would not let the optimistic timeline become a deal breaker especially since you have mentioned you expect this to take longer.  Some of us are optimistic in our scheduling and some of us expect the unexpected.  Good luck!

    bobtownsuz thanked Top Drawer Carpentry LLC
  • 4 years ago

    I so much appreciate all this feedback and advice. It has been a real struggle to find someone I trust for this job. At some point you start second guessing your second guesses and then you just can't think straight anymore! Many thanks to this community.

  • 4 years ago

    There is sort of an element of blind faith that you have made the correct choices.


    You appear to be doing appropriate due diligence and when I have had to make important decisions I ask myself whether I will be okay with the outcome in terms of feeling I had done everything possible to get the best outcome. For example, I needed an operation so I researched the "procedure", the various techniques; asked my doctor for referals; checked background of surgeon and asked surgeon how many procedures he did each week/year - FWIW frequency of a specific surgery is one of the best indicators of positive outcome as is the number of these kinds of cases a hospital deals with - but I digress.


    With a GC I think that to some extent personal references that you can verify are extremely important. When I was planning my remodel, I was able to view some works in progress so I could see the quality of the work. I was also able to verify that the GC (and my designer) were not going to flake out but were reliable and trustworthy.


    I did take pictures of the construction of my shower but since construction expertise isn't my strong point I relied on my designer to act as my project manager since she had construction expertise and so was able to ensure the job was being done correctly and also provide me with input in terms of what were minor issues that would not be an issue when the job was complete. If you don't have this kind of expert you might think about whether you have a friend who can take a look at certain critical points like when the shower is being built.

    bobtownsuz thanked Helen
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I think if the unrealistic timeline is the only negative with the one contractor, and a short timeline is not particularly important to you, and he does not feel compelled to deliver in a short timeline for his own reasons, I am not sure I would count that against him. I use a number of people who always have unrealistic timelines, always think they will get it done faster than they do, but also always do a good job. And they are never start on their projected date because they are always behind schedule. And people wait for them because they are generally worth waiting for.

    The time I needed the bathroom done quickly, that guy had it down to a science, including permits and inspections and there were a lot of things he would not do, based upon that timeline--like he would only do a bathtub or a solid piece shower base. The base could be acrylic, cast iron, terrazzo, solid surface, whatever, but either he provided it or if it was something special, it was onsite before he would even start the job--no tile shower floors or highly customized stuff. His specialty was quick turnaround, high quality but nothing elaborate bathrooms for single-bathroom condos, coops or houses where people could not be without. That's all he did.

  • 4 years ago

    We are having our own struggles getting tile work done. We’ve now had two installers back out on the planned start date. My advice is to be very clear about start date.