The decor mix will add a nice pattern to the kitchen as your countertops have very minimal veining.

No 3

I voted #3, but #4 could be cool too, depending on what look you want. I think #3 is a little more traditional, #4 more modern. The only reason I didn't vote #4 is because I like the two tones in #3, since it's just a lot of white with the cabinets already

between number 2 and number 4. vote went to 4 but with your instinct/ gut lean toward matte , in a way, that might be the better . number two looks very good. you have good lighting and already a shade down to cut glare???? so the value of a glossy tile in your white LA kitchen doesn't compel avoidance of the beautiful matte. small kitchens/ without illumination or windows benefit from gloss....get the matte if you like it.

I don’t think you could go wrong with any of them, except the 2x20. If any tiles are warped or your wall bows any, you will have issues with lippage

I like number 1 or number 4 stacked vertically like the way number 4 shows. Reason being your long windows and that wall. It’s def a different look so try and lay some to see if you like it. Only thought be careful with zellige they don’t always have pencil or end pieces and sometimes hard to find installer who knows how to do them. I think gloss is a good idea for kitchen!

@Micaela Carucci I went with one of the matte options; the one that had the least amount of votes (!). I am mostly satisfied with the final look. I would "perfect" it by having rectified edges and a little bit more grout -- installer left no space whatsover in between tiles. By the time I caught it, it was too late.

Fez White Matte 2.5*5

Feel free to PM me if you'd like more pictures.