Software
Houzz Logo Print
caroline_clancy32

Help picking backsplash and cabinet color?

4 years ago

Planning to paint my cabinets and island and redo my backsplash soon. Currently the cabinets are a warm red and the backsplash is this impossible to clean beige stacked stone. Trim is going to be painted BM Chantilly lace

My granite does have some grey in it, so I’m trying to decide if I should do a grey-blue backsplash with light grey cabinets, grey backsplash with grey-blue cabinets, or white cabinets? I’m worried the blue backsplash makes the countertop look too warm, the right tile is my favorite but I’m still hunting for more samples.

Below are some tile samples I picked up & my countertops, a picture of what it currently looks like and my inspiration pic (SW silver strand)

Comments (16)

  • 4 years ago

    I would change the counters and backsplash, but leave the cabinets alone.

  • 4 years ago

    Here’s a better picture of the counter. The cabinets and island have to be painted unfortunately, the finish is not in good shape. Creamy white could be an option

  • 4 years ago

    Ditto what @Skippack Tile & Stone said. I know traditional styles aren't "in" right now, but those are objectively beautiful cabinets. Gray is on its way out or out already according to a lot of people, so don't twist yourself in a pretzel to introduce gray. If you like gray regardless of trends you're going to have to get a new countertop. If you don't like the style of the cabinets you should be looking at refacing. It is more expensive than painting, but less expensive than a complete remodel.

  • 4 years ago

    I’m not necessarily set on Grey, I really just want to lighten up the kitchen and move away from the cherry tones in the cabinet & backsplash. Would a mushroom beige tone like this work?

  • 4 years ago

    The tile sample you have on the far left of your picture is the closest match to the counters. So cabinet paint should be the same or lighter. Also look at the tile sample placed perpendicular to the counters as that is the way you're going to see backsplash. That changes the angle of the light hitting it and might change your perception of the color. Look at BM Simply White or SW Alabaster for cabinet color. You are going to be the best judge of it since colors look different IRL. We can only get so close when we're looking at colors on monitors.

  • 4 years ago

    Be sure whoever is painting your cabinets that they use a great primer first like Permawhite, or Bin stain sealer, so the oils from the wood do not bleed through and yellow the paint color you’re trying to achieve.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Honestly, I would color match your island color and redo everything in that color.

    That color looks good with your granite.

    The backsplash can be a version of that light color. The back should be chosen last, after you’ve painted the cabinets.

  • 4 years ago

    Taking everyone’s advice into account, I think I’m going to abandon blue and grey for now and instead opt for a warm greige/taupe on the cabinets and a warm white backsplash.

    One day I’d love to swap the granite for clean white quartz but for now I’ve got to work with it

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    if you wait until the cabs are painted, then you can upload a current pic that shows them, the granite and the flooring together. it's easier to pick out a tile.

    make sure your lighting is upgraded to a 3500-4000K Temp LED bulb for the cleanest light. In your pic you can really see a lot of yellow

    Looks like your granite is Santa Cecelia Light, Giallo Ornamental, colonial white, Or White Ornamental granite (this granite goes by more than one name. It's one of the original granites that hit the market over 25 years ago.


    here's one you can read about and the colors she chose (although I think the gray has too much blue in it)


    https://www.shanty-2-chic.com/2012/09/painted-cabinets.html

    a soft white is prob your best bet,


    here's Ornamental White. does yours have these taupe/gray tones in it?


    If so, these tones should work



    City Loft or Modern Gray would be close to how this looks. or it could be a creamy white. hard to tell w/this lighting.












    here's one w/a blue gray tile.


  • 4 years ago

    @Beth H @Beth H thank you for your thorough response! The lighting in my kitchen is currently very warm, I’m planning to replace the bulbs with a more neutral light like you said.

    I think Ornamental White is on the money, it’s got the greys, some taupe tones, and the occasional reddish purple blotch. These image you shared looks closest! It’s for sure not Santa Cecilia, I grew up in a house with that granite and it’s way more yellow than mine is now so I think the yellow in my picture must be the lighting.

    I used the Sherwin Williams color picker and got Anew Grey and Revere Pewter out of it which are very similar to the colors you shared (adding those to my samplize order!). I think a taupey grey like that with an warm white backsplash or vice versa and do White dove for my trim and the cabinets and a warm grey backsplash would work well.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    CC, there are two types of Santa Cecelia,,,,Light and the Gold. The gold one was pretty popular. The lighter one went by diff names as well as "Light". you prob had the gold.




    as I've said, your granite has at least 4 diff names that I know of.

    sometimes I think it's very similar to River White or Kashmir White. (or some others. every stone place gives the slabs their own names)






    a gray w/taupe undertone would be perfect for you.


    Stonington Gray


    River Reflections


    Coventry Gray


    What's the flooring?

    get some samples of some othe other taupes I posted. you may like those too. I used Light Pewter in my own kitchen

    see if any of these work. if the white in your granite is more yellow, these whites should look good with it. If, after you upgrade your lighting, find out it's a brighter white, go with one of the brighter whites like Oxford white or Pure White


  • 4 years ago

    For future searchers, I ended up going with Edgecomb Gray per Beth’s advice and Grays Harbor for the island and I think it works splendidly! I still have to finish painting the cabinet fronts and choose a backsplash (open to suggestions!) but very happy so far

  • 4 years ago

    great colors CC. did you ever upgrade the lighting to 4000K? in your top pic it looks really warm w/the counterotp

  • 4 years ago

    @Beth H. : is the master of paint colors! That made the counters take on a whole new life!

  • 4 years ago

    That’s next on my list! I’m getting new hardware and pendant lights. Black reads a little more farmhouse than is my style so now that the cabinets are brighter i’m thinking brass. Here’s how it looks on revere pewter which is on the same strip as Edgecomb gray.

    As an aside, I’ve never worked so hard on a project! Think twice if you’re ever thinking of painting cabinets yourself. But I highly recommend a sprayer

Sponsored
High Point Cabinets
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars21 Reviews
Columbus' Experienced Custom Cabinet Builder | 4x Best of Houzz Winner