That’s a trip hazard…paint the riser white to match the other risers (the tread is the flat part).

Paint, no question.

Either way works. I like it natural.

White gets scuffed more easily but I think it might look better. Just get some Bristol board and tape to see if you prefer it lighter.

How would it look Java gel stained to match the handrails?

No to the java. Paint it white

OK, white paint it will be. Thanks!

paint it, it's part of the stairs, not floor.

Paint it white.

similar to yours w/the java. they did the treads to match the handrails. what do you think about that?

and yes, white for the bottom riser

here's a railing in black, white risers, and the lighter oak treads.

if you ever decide to upgrade the spindles/newel posts:

or add a cool antelope runner

Matching treads look great, but we recently refinished our entire three flights of stairs before we gel stained. It was a major,expensive project so I think we will be happy simply painting the bottom white.

yeah, I don't blame you. I think the treads look fine.

changing out the spindles would be a better upgrade down the road.