I would go with a light body color, Stucco finish should look natural, as in Sandstone, or similar.

Lighter Trim, what you have is a nice soft color.

keep the garage door light, similar to the body of the home, and forget the shutters, the style is odd, and doesn't fit the window (the other windows don't have room for shutters so why on just one? I would paint the ceiling arch of the entrance a light blue. A Natural wood door would be attractive, if not, something light and inviting.

You have a lovely flowerbed, I'd trim down the bushes under the window to expose the trim a bit.

Can you add a light fixture beside the front door? or is their lighting in the arch?

Your house is perfect as is. I would simply remove the random shutters and pronounce it done. People spend $$$$ to have a wood finish front door and garage door and you already have it and it goes great with the stucco color.

You have white windows. The white trim works great with the windows. Don't be swade by the move to Black accents. For some homes it's correct, for yours it's not.

You can go with off-white for body. It would pop up trim, but it is not so stark as white with medium or dark colors.