To be honest, I think there are better choices out there. But my comment could be informed by my resistance to round mirrors.

Of the choices above, i like upper right. Lower left reminds me of a porthole.

A scientist would like matchy! The one with blue of course. Matchy looks less poor....it's the world we live in! I LOVE matchy or BALANCE...!

I love the demiluna painted chest-- it ties all the blues together! I prefer the bottom left mirror with the other pieces in the room.

FWIW.. i do NOT think an eclectic, unmatched room looks "poor"... or that a matched room looks "less poor".

I like he bottom left. I love a simple round mirror as part of a vignette, and they are in right now. My DD has Ikea's Stockholm; it has a cute little shelf built in.

I took a pic of these mirrors at Home Goods yesterday. The covering is textured like straw.

Great chest!

I love the curves of this, especially for this room.

https://www.anthropologie.com/shop/clemente-rattan-mirror?category=mirrors&color=014&type=STANDARD&size=One%20Size&quantity=1

https://www.westelm.com/products/elinor-rattan-wall-mirror-w3988/

World Market

Also — wicker could be painted. You get texture, DD gets matching. :)

I love a round mirror over a chest. I too think you can find some better choices. Although not round, i love the first one Jinx posted.

Of the two you posted, left, the solid frame.

I didn't see the chest. Withdraw my photo as the blues clash.

I think this would be very nice and work with the vibe of the room:

https://www.rejuvenation.com/catalog/collections/bentwood-round-wood-mirror/products/628fe302fc1ebc4a0ede9c9b?cm_ven=PLA&cm_cat=Google&cm_pla=default&cm_ite=E5049_14332641991&gclid=Cj0KCQjwhqaVBhCxARIsAHK1tiP66KcHCPitIgQfw998QZpeKo9Ko6jvkdfYre1COsd-kp5cZ8jZrI8aAu2dEALw_wcB

I tried a couple of the wicker styles and they definitely add an ”extra” vibe i did not anticipate….thank heavens for Morpholio. Rather, thank Mtn as i think you suggested it years ago. I had just found this which is very similar to the one just posted, but a little heavier. From Wayfair

I really like the tone of this wood, also the width and depth of the frame I’m trying to avoid gold anything at DD’s request and this wood is the closest i can come to that tone 😎

I would use something different on chest, those candlesticks are to camouflage something that was on the chest in the store.

Wall color throughout the house is a pleasing taupe, all trim crisp white.

I like it a lot!

I like the last round mirror you just posted. You have a lucky daughter to have decorating her space. Everything looks beautiful!

I like the latest one much better than the other two. 👍

I really lke the last one as well. I have this simple round mirror in my foyer. Target! I bought one in gold as well and sometimes alternate. The scale here is distorted as I was trying to keep myself out of the photo.

The other great thing about this mirror is that it makes me look ten pounds thinner!

I like the last one and the one Teeda shared. Bonus for the thinning powers!

Teeda please send that mirror this way. I'll need two.

I think I would like some sort of arch topped mirror with that chest.

Mtn, I have a very good quality mirror in my l/r. Seems to more correctly reflect my image. So sometimes I check myself between the two mirrors and choose to believe I'm somewhere in the middle, lol!

I recently purchased this mirror for our guest bath. It is very nice, solid and maybe the color family you seek.

https://www.overstock.com/Home-Garden/36-Large-Round-Natural-Wood-Wall-Mirror-w-Decorative-Wood-Beads-36-x-2-x-36Round/32085745/product.html

Teeda, LOVE your mirror, and Jmck yours too!

Pal, I haven’t seen an arch top mirror I really like. Many are gothic arches with mullions, and the narrow point at the top means a narrower mirror. DD doesn’t like gold leaf or silver, and I am trying to stay away from another painted finish above the demilune. So far I havent turned up even one suitable Palladian style mirror in my google search for images.

The round mirrors you've shown seem to overpower the chest. Maybe the scale is off? How wide is the chest (which is beyond perfect I need to add) 💙 if the size if right the lower left is my pick

I think the chest along the back edge is 42”. I was looking for a 30” mirror, mainly because a smaller one would necessitate corbels with something on them on either side, or sconces or prints and I think they would perceive that as fussy. You may be right about the scale. I have been googling like mad, my fingertips are tingling!

I'm feeling that you need something less predictable up there. It's almost looking too perfect.

This isn't over the top deco but just right. Some deco styles other than round might work.

You're right about excess "stuff" to fill a void. That size mirror requires nothing more.

From Houzz: 30" Free Ship Jun 20-22

Nautical Decorative Wall Mirror, Rattan, Royal Blue · More Info

Round Checquered Wall Mirror · More Info

Maybe for just this once, let DD have her first choice (inattracitve gray wood). She may very well change her mind once she sees it in situ. Sometimes, we need to make our own mistakes and eventually come to realizing our own style.

Please understand, this is not a criticism of anything you have done or are doing. I know you are having fun decorating for them and trying to get their input and guide them to what you think is going to look the best.

Oh Cyn… you do not know me very well, lol. The ugly mirror is not DD’s first choice, she just has it already and is thinking of utility. Utility is all very well but not when the item is a) ugly and b) inappropriate, and her mirror ticks both those boxes. Using it would be a crime against decorating, they would not see anything wrong with it and it would stay in place forever. Not happening!

Jt, I would also like something less predictable, which is why i’m leaning towards rattan or wicker. The one you posted is a great size but the shape looks like it can’t make up its mind.

Arapaho, i LOVE that mirror and would be willing to glaze that red with burnt orange to suit the brief.

Jinx, no furniture refinishing for me. Have you forgotten the sad tale of my Christmas deer? Besides, the finish on this piece is exquisite. Sound idea though that would admittedly give us more options.

My post disappeared, sorry! I found another pic and was trying to add it. :D

I like your deer!

I understand not wanting to change it, though, since the finish is so good.

Cannot find that mirror on Overstock. i have put in every search parameter and keep getting outlandish results like leather sofas. Something must be wrong with their search function. Do you know the name of the mfg or product?

Here it is:

https://www.overstock.com/Home-Garden/Camak-Indoor-Wood-Round-Mirror-by-Christopher-Knight-Home/32573677/product.html?refccid=RLQT344B75KK6JSBE2QK6D4J7M&searchidx=23&kwds=&rfmt=style%3ABohemian+%26amp%3B+Eclectic&option=60415261

I like that!

I like that rope wrapped mirror from Houzza, Arapaho! The nautical one would not work; they aren’t nautical, they are horsey. How does this one look? The plate is an 8” IIRC from Anthropologie. I am trying to figure out how to use it 🤔

I think that one looks great! And love the plate - surely a spot will be found.

I take back what I said about round mirrors. That one looks fantastic!

ETA: could the plate be used as a catchall on the top of the chest? Or upright in an easel on the chest? Is there a fireplace in the room? If so, could it go on the mantel on a stand?

That’s exactly what i was thinking, BBstx. Perhaps a rustic thing or two on it as well to calm the unrest 😎

The curtains came today and they are a dark rust. Fingers crossed they will like them, otherwise we will end up with plain Jane natural linen curtains that — while perfectly lovely— are everywhere.