Software
Houzz Logo Print
thekeller4

Cabinet Depth Refrigerator vs. Standard Depth

4 years ago

We will have a built in cabinet depth refrigerator on our main level and are planning to purchase another refrigerator/freezer for our lower level.


Our Kitchen Designer would like us to do cabinet depth for the lower level, but I'm wondering if I will ever have a need/desire for standard depth.


Are there items that definitely will not fit in a cabinet depth?

Comments (8)

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I haven't found anything that doesn't fit. It is side x side refrigerators that have an issue because some wide stuff won't fit but counter depth refrigerators are wide and have enough depth for everything I have to fit in it. I think a major complaint with side x side is that pizza boxes don't fit or if you get trays of items. That isn't an issue with a counter depth - either French door or regular door - because you can store things the width of the refrigerator unlike a side x side and generally most of the middles have a full length compatment for deli items (for example) plus the two standard produce bins which are half the width of the refrigerator.

    FWIW Consumers' Reports had an article on refrigerators and found that people with counter depth refrigerators were fine with the storage capabilities.

    In my own experience my new counter depth refrigerator is quite large enough and seems more efficient because things don't get shoved in the back so the storage is as good as my standard depth was which had inefficient storage.

    What I did have to get used to is having the freezer on the bottom that pulls out because with my old top freezer model I could shove stuff into it and jam the door closed. With the baskets on my new refrigerator I have to make sure that items aren't stacked too high so it closes - on the plus size I don't have quantities of years old stuff that is hiding in the back and bottom and which I had to throw out periodically since everything is visible.

  • 4 years ago

    Thank you Helen! This is so helpful!!

  • 4 years ago

    Remember that "counter-depth" refers only to the depth of the refrigerator cabinet without the doors and handles. The LG LRMDC2306 (for example) is 29 5/8" deep with the doors (but without the handles) so it extends nearly six inches beyond the adjacent cabinets. In contrast the Blomberg BRFD2230SS is 26 13/16" deep so it extends only three inches. Of course you sacrifice interior space with the shallower appliance.

  • 4 years ago

    I’ve had both types. I really hated my KitchenAid built in counter depth (from previous owners). Yes, it was less space but also the configuration didn’t work for me and adjustments were limited. So, considering the possibilities you have to move shelves, etc, as well as space.

  • 4 years ago

    So I have an LG standard depth. It was a struggle getting it in my house because of all the interior doors it had to pass through. 


    With that, I absolutely love my fridge. However. I am only 5'3 and I struggle reaching anything in the back

  • 4 years ago

    Frig headaches... We have had every type of fridge you can imagine due to gov't transfer jobs, new houses and 'lifetime' changes.

    We both hate 'regular non counter depth'. Ours was in the middle of a longish wall. It stuck out 7 inches. 7 inches doesn't seem like much in your mind but looked terrible. The bottom freezer held a lot but everyone you wanted ice. Water you had to pull out the bottom drawer. We got a 'counter depth' and it is wonderful! Yes, not as much fits inside and not as much adjusting of shelving. AN, even though the counter depth was 3 feet bigger it doesn't hold as much😒. It doesn't really matter to us as we have an extra freezer in our laundryroom. If we ever move again... there will be a separate fridge and freezer. Both in a kitchen but separate. Now, would just have to consider that most single fridges do not have water from the exterior door. And single freezers do not have door ice. Sigh....

  • 4 years ago

    I don't drink the water or use the ice from my side-by-side. I use store-bought ice and gallons of spring water. Those limitations would not bother me.


  • 4 years ago

    ILOVEMYLIFE- Sorry to intrude. Do people realize the contamination/bacteria/molds, etc of commercial drinking systems such as the tubing from tanks? I am hoping an ice company would routinely clean their systems but I doubt it 'routinely once a year????'. Even any hospital I worked at only did it on each machine once a year. Unless your home water is of bad taste/quality you are far better to use extreme water filters, and flush your system at the refrigerator . a secondary extreme filter or reverse osmosis system at frog/freezer. Then a couples times s year disconnect the line at the water source and flush with 10% chlorine(bleach) solution throughout water lines that provide the water/ice. Then touch out the drinking water/ice lines by dumping the water/ice for at least 1 gal of water where the water comes out of the fridge and throw out several batches of ice cubes. Stores/gas stations etc where there are soda fountain machines are well documented for bacteria (rarely viruses) throughout the machines. If you ever saw the insides of those machines you would be surprised, disgusted and doubt you would ever buy any again. Promise. A year or so in your state public health department would change your views on alot of things! And working in the emergency room. Most won't kill ya but gives you an education!