Software
Houzz Logo Print
jeremy_buford

How to fix this drywall mess?

4 years ago

We are building a custom home and are planning to move in next week. After painting was complete both us and builder noticed the drywall had a TON of imperfections. Mostly due to sanding too hard. the drywall guy sent in his best crew to fix it and did a ton of repairs. We then paid painters to repaint and it looks almost worse than before. What should we do?



Comments (8)

  • 4 years ago

    Shift to a matte sheen. Or reframe the house. Your choice.

  • 4 years ago

    One of the painters mentioned switching to a flat paint, but wasn’t sure if that would cover everything. The drywall guys mentioned texturing the ceiling.


    The walls seem fine!

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    From here, the walls look bad too.


    Did the painters repaint everything or just the patches?

    What paint and primer were used?

    I'd never suggest anything other than a flat or matte sheen on ceilings, especially one like yours where the light from the window will highlight any imperfection.


    If the drywall work looked good (I would fix it if it did not), I'd mask, spray primer over the entire ceiling, back roll it, then spray 2 coats of paint, back rolling each with an 18" roller with at least a 1/2" nap giving the paint just a bit of texture.


    I would spot prime the patches with Gardz from Zinsser, or a shellac based primer like B-I-N also from Zinsser.




  • 4 years ago

    I would definitely say flat paint on the ceiling. Maybe its a geographic specific, but down here (texas) almost all houses have flat ceilings and the only time you'd do something else is if you have a high end smooth finish on the ceilings (level 5 of slick coat - not sure what they call it, but we considered it and it would have added several weeks and tens of thousands of dollars). with all the sun reflecting, a flat finish hides a lot of imperfections.

  • 4 years ago

    Thanks for the feedback. In the picture, it has been primed and first coat of paint, still one more today. The walls were just painted and still wet so that is what most of the imperfections are, especially over the doorway. We will give flat on the ceiling a go and see how it goes. Here is another picture of an area that was dry where you can see ceiling is way worse than walls. Still just primer and one coat of paint.


  • 4 years ago

    Answering some more questions. They only primered the repairs, but repaiting entire surface with first coat of paint. Not sure what primer was used. Paint was something like Pro 400 from Sherwin Williams.


    And yes, the painter was using an 18” roller roller, but not sure on thr 1/2” thing to add a little texture.

  • 4 years ago

    It's the other way around. Flat sheen is the starting point and standard for ceilings, you don't have to try it out. You can try satin/semigloss, and you found out what happens. Also, the primer on repairs should extend past joint compound onto the sander's scratch marks next to the compound repairs.

  • 4 years ago

    Flat for ceiling and matte for walls. I prefer to use Benjamin Moore Aura. More expensive, but I think it is worth it from my experience painting with it and living with it for many years.