Software
Houzz Logo Print
kmcol88

Will we regret “trendy” appliances?

4 years ago

We’re undergoing a full kitchen reno. My style and goal is for a classic traditional kitchen that will remain beautiful and functional for years to come. We usually steer away from anything too trendy. That being said, I love the style of the cafe/ilve/blue star gas range. But are they too trendy? Will they look comical and silly in ~5 years when instagram influencers stop using them in their kitchen renovations?


The range can be my splurge, if I want it, because I cook a lot. I am okay with paying $4,000 for something pretty as long as it is also a great appliance. (I should note I struck ilve from my short list because it has much less cubic space in the oven than our current one.) But the $2,000 GE also looks nice and meets all my needs.


Cafe fridges are beautiful too but thats not my splurge. If i went over budget there I would choose panel ready.


What are the thoughts on these styles? Have they always been classic but I just never knew? Or is it a passing trend that I will regret in 5 years?



Comments (12)

  • 4 years ago

    Since you cook a lot, aren't the functions of the range the most important thing...not if strangers on Instagram put them into their kitchens? My gas range fit my cooking style, and my budget.

  • 4 years ago

    Blue Star has looked good for a long time to a certain set of people. My husband's family had a Garland (predesessor brand, I believe, commercial only at the time) range at their house in Ct since the late 70s. My mother wanted that look since the early 80s. If the aesthetic suits you, then it suits you.

    I make no mention of capabilities, because you can cook as well on a high end modern looking appliance, as opposed to what you are discussing. I love induction, but gas is awesome too, especially a properly vented Blue Star.

  • 4 years ago

    I’m a fan of Five Star ranges, which are more obscure than Blue Star but basically the same on terms of a pro-look range.


    I put one in my old house back in 1998 along with some lovely shaker style cherry cabinets. Sold the house a few years later but have seen the inside several times since.


    Most recently, the owners painted the (now fully red, perfect patina) cherry cabinets grey. But the old range is still there. Saw the photos for the real estate listing when it sold last year. Still looks good with the more modern vibe of grey cabinets/white counters/brass accents.

  • 4 years ago

    @lucky998877 yes of course. I wouldnt choose or not choose something just because I saw it on social media. I guess my worry is, those types of appliances seem to be on trend at the moment, and will it date my kitchen if I put it in? Or are these brands and styles actually more timeless than i think? Maybe I just dont get out much :)

  • 4 years ago

    If they are going to look comical and silly in five years they almost certainly already look that way.


    I'd pick kitchen appliances first for performance and second for if they look good to me. I really can't imagine giving a rats a$$ about what some TikTok "influencer" thinks about it. Qualiy is, I think, the best indicator of "timelessness". Well designed, well made stuff, even if in a style that is not the current fashion, perseveres. A vintage O'Keefe and Merrit stove still looks and works great 70 years later (and carries a commensurate resale value) even though the influencers have probably never heard of one.


    This is a problem in that most current appliances are made as throwaway items designed to last only a few years. Some of the commercial look brands are actually pretty well made, but more importantly are not festooned with useless electronic geegaws and use replaceable off-the-shelf generic parts.


    We've got a Capital Culinarian range (perhaps trendy when we bought it) and a 25 year old SZ refrigerator (definitely not trendy when we bought it used a decade ago). I'm perfectly happy with both, as they both do their jobs admirably, neither has anything unrelated to their basic function, and kind of look like what they are.

  • 4 years ago

    I read somewhere that gas ranges will be phased out due to emissions. Not sure where I read it, maybe Consumer Reports or somewhere else. Has anyone seen anything about this?


    Jane

  • 4 years ago

    Harvest Gold and Avocado Green really date an appliance (if you were alive back then-LOL). I stay with neutral colors when buying appliances to prevent those old 70s flashbacks. ;-)

  • 4 years ago

    OTOH, given the interest when I sold a suite of rather decrepit pink 1950's appliances that probably now grace a beautiful MCM restoration, can the resurrection of harvest gold and avocado green be far behind?

    (I loved the pink oven/cooktop/sink, and was sorry to see it go, but avocado green counts as one of those things that was ugly from the get-go. I can remember my mother re-doing her kitchen in it and my reaction of "what is she thinking?". At 14 my opinion on colors wasn't solicited. )

  • 4 years ago

    Re: gas ranges

    No new gas hookups for heat, hot water, or cooking stoves in NYC in New buildings as early as 2024.

    Given the amount of existing gas cooking stoves in Manhattan (I am not sure I have ever been in an apartment with an electric stove), I think it will take 50 years or more for it to have much of an effect in existing real estate, and they will have to continue selling gas ranges in Manhattan in order to replace failed units in existing buildings most of which do not have electrical capacity to handle a dozen, fifty, 100 electrical cooking appliances that they didn't have before. The transition is going to take a Long time.

  • 4 years ago

    Get what you want, especially if you cook a lot!! I would not base my purchase decision on whether or not something was “on trend.” If you think the price is worth it, go ahead and buy it. What time is dinner? 🙂

  • 4 years ago

    These ranges are classic style, you just never knew that! Enjoy!