Are you asking solely about the door styles, or are the finishes part of the question as well?

Just the styles - The cabinet maker just threw them together quickly for me so I could see something in real life vs pictures. They aren’t finished at this stage but will eventually be just standard white.

Either style is nice. I don't think you can make a mistake between those two options.

Thanks to everyone who voted! I am so surprised that most voted for the recessed style. I haven’t seen it in many photos and I was scared it was dated.

You could do something in-between those two. Instead of the double bead of your right-side door, you could do a single bead. That way you get the additional decorative factor, but not so detailed as a double bead door.

This is just a pic I saw on a 5-second Google Images search, but you could see more online or ask your cabinet maker.

I did a bevel shaker. It is easier to keep clean than the straight edge

I did a rounded trim piece inside of my shaker cabinet, because the shaker was just too plain/flat looking. This was my sample door below. Scale of top drawer stiles/rails was done wrong on the sample. Center recess is actually larger to allow room for fingers to clear a pull.

I did shaker with a single bead because the look went better with my home. See if you can get a sample with a single bead.

The two rooms I have with a shaker style door, I went with a 45° edge instead of 90°. I felt it softened the appearance a bit. Photos of a couple samples at my cabinet maker.

We used these.