Software
Houzz Logo Print
matt_p97

What sheen for shiplap

4 years ago

I am doing one of those shiplap builtins for the tv. i am doing oak shelves. what sheen should i paint the shiplap? everything is gonna be bm white dove or sw pure white (still undecided). i know semi gloss is easier to clean and more durable but that isnt the concern for me should it be matte to match the walls or semi gloss to match the trim?


ty for the feedback i am driving myself crazy and would love some advice

Comments (33)

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Why match either? Go with satin so it stands out by itself. Satin is a very attractive hardy finish and easy to clean. (There will be the inevitable fingerprints and dust lol.) IMO satin. It's gonna be so beautiful!

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Eggshell or Satin finish. SW Pure White would be my choice but not sure what your adjoining wall color is?

    Matt P thanked Flo Mangan
  • PRO
    4 years ago

    I would do walls in same color but Flat finish.

    Matt P thanked Flo Mangan
  • 4 years ago

    @Flo Mangan not a fan of dove white?

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Ship lap ship has sailed and sunk please rethink that choice . At least show pics of what the space will look like with what you are planning.

  • 4 years ago


    love it

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Shiplap is ETERNAL however like every design element it has its place.

    eta…..satin finish would be my choice for your application

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    I would not select a sheen glossier than eggshell. I like when the shiplap matches the wall sheen.


  • 4 years ago

    The sheen you choose will depend as much on which brand & line of paint as it will on "flat, eggshell, or satin" descriptions. SW paint is normally a lower sheen than Benjamin Moore even when they are both called the same.

    Even between lines of the same brand, the sheen varies.

    You can always go to the TDS sheet for the exact product and look for the sheen level to compare more closely.

  • 4 years ago

    Can I ask how you came to these two color choices?


    SW Pure White is very close to BM White Heron

    BM White Dove is very close to SW Alabaster


    But SW Pure White isn't anything like BM White Dove. One is cool, one is warm.


    When doing trim and walls the same white I would be picking the white that works best with my flooring and furniture, and meets the overall aesthetic that I was going for. Only one of these two would hit the mark.





    Have you painted large samples and tested them? If I were painting walls and trim I would probably be painting 1/2 sheets of drywall to test which color I wanted and I would be really sure before I did this much work.



  • 4 years ago

    @Jennifer Hogan before i did how much work? What are you talking about? seriously. what are you talking about?

  • 4 years ago

    @Matt P, "i am driving myself crazy and would love some advice..."

    Painting is a LOT of work. Most of the work is in the prep, part of which is picking the color. It's best to buy samples and paint large poster boards so they can be looked at from different angles and in different lighting (very sunny to evening or night time), to compare and contrast with your furniture and other fixed elements.

    Jennifer is one of the most thorough and helpful people to post on this site, so you might want to re-read what she wrote.


  • 4 years ago

    Post a picture of your room with flooring and furniture and we may be in a better position to help you decide which color white works best with the rest of colors you will be using.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    i am going to paint samples of several colors. The room is not finished being built yet. But yes Those two colors are very popular and sort of in lead right now based on stuff i have seen around and their popularity. I will most certainly be trying them out before i commit to anything. I do plan to do the walls trim ceiling the same color but different sheens. then i thought about the built in and was unsure if it should be the wall or trim sheen, hence the question. And i dont agree that white dove and pure white are that much different They are different but not extremely different. I could see pure white being cooler but i dont think its considered to be stark white by any means. And yes white dove can be warmer depending on the light. In any event i appreciate advice. and i was hoping for some when i raised the question. But i think its worth a moment to highlight that i have not done anything yet and i am familiar with the sage wisdom of the internet regarding how to test paint colors and etc.

  • 4 years ago

    oh and there is no flooring or furniture yet.,


  • 4 years ago

    id also add that when you paint the walls trim and ceiling the same color but different sheens it most definitely tricks your eye. White dove in a room painted like the aforementioned most certainly looks pretty white. However if you paint the walls dove and the trim Chantilly then it will most definitely look yellow.

  • 4 years ago

    Your putting the horse before the cart.

    There are literally thousands of paint colors, but furniture and flooring colors are much more limited. Pick those first.


    Is this for a home you will be living in? Do you have a favorite color (not neutral)?

    Do you own any art that you love and want to display? What colors are in the art?


    If you want to Private message me with your phone number I can walk you through the decision making process over the phone. Easier than trying to talk you through via the internet.

  • 4 years ago

    As for sheen as a general rule I use eggshell on the walls, satin on the trim and flat on the ceiling.

    I only like to paint every 10 years or so, and this works for me. Paints are getting better and better, but the eggshell still gives you a bit more washability than the matte or flat. I have a dog and she will get the outside corners dirty and I like to be able to wipe them down and remove the oils without messing up the paint job. Find the same around door knobs, light switches, anywhere hands tend to touch.


    I would do the shiplap the same as the walls. I think a satin or semi gloss on the inside of the box where the TV is going would cause some distractive reflection.

  • 4 years ago

    i really dont think i am putting anything before the cart. My question was pretty direct as to "how" i should consider shiplap ....wall or trim. And i think i have my answer. I am leaning to painting it Matte Sheen which is the sheen that i usually do on my walls.


    However the convo has no evolved into paint color selection and in that regard i havent shared enough info so we are butting heads a little. So let me do that. We are finishing our basement. ITs a huge space with 10 foot cellings and tons of windows. Its not a traditional basement by any means. We are finishing 2000 sq ft of a 3k sq ft basdement. We have not picked out furniture or even floors at this point. But we are leaning to calypso LVP from coretec bc we love the color of the natural oak look. But its not a done deal bc i cant stand that its only 48 inch. I dont want the big rooms of the basement to look like a puzzle. So we may end up doing engineered oak. Pretty much the only thing we picked out so far is that we want to do satin brass hardware and light fuxtures and we want to do a "white" for the walls. But i dont want stark. The trend has evolved i think from that.


    As far as colors, i have considered tons. But i want to stick to a off white. White dove is probably the most loved white out there. So i have to consider it. Pure white is the color that i always see and ask "what white is that" and it ends up being pure white. Based on my research both are off whites and BOTH can go cool or warm. However pure white tends to be more cool in most lighting when compared to white dove. Both have a similar LRV and both are considered off whites.


    By all means please help.....

  • 4 years ago

    you are probably right that i should pick the floors first. But we have a general idea of what we want. we just have to get there. Pure white is the hottest white paint right now,

  • 4 years ago

    and u are right about the sheen competing with the tv....good thought.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Matt, there is no B.M. Dove White.

    Calling it shiplap is a misnomer, unless every board is joined at the top and bottom with a rabbet joint, it is just paneling. Shiplap is used outside, and on boats to repel water. Joanna Gaines does fabulous things, but she doesn't know her shiplap.

  • 4 years ago

    ok white dove sorry


  • 4 years ago

    LOL at judianna’s comments regarding shiplap. Shiplap will be tied forevermore (for me) to Joanna Gaines and her Texas farmhouses. Not really a look I’m going for in my house.

    But then, for all we know, Matt lives in Texas.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    I think you meant BM White Dove vs SW Pure White. Here is the DNA (color scientific notation for those two colors.) As to “sheen” level for a area with “shiplap” I would tend to use a higher sheen in entertainment area simply because it tends to be more durable. However, with the conditions you describe, I would wait til your space is more defined and flooring and lighting are selected. Your lighting will affect your perceptions of all colors. The main difference between these two colors is what we call the Chroma level. The higher that number the more colorful and possible “graying”. Most clients today prefer the Pure White so it doesn’t go yellow. If you want the entertainment section to stand out more and take a lot of use, go with a semi-gloss. If concerned more about aesthetics, go eggshell walls and trim. Ceiling flat. Hope that helps. I have SW Alabaster flat in our whole house with mainly north and south exposure. We love it.

    Matt P thanked Flo Mangan
  • 4 years ago

    Thsts awesime thsts the look we want slightly more white thiugh we may do wlwbaster in the bedroom and bathroom . sounds like you recommend pure white for me

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I like walls, trim and ceiling all the same color but different finishes. We have a window sized for a regular door and then went with french doors so abutting trim different height but that's what happens when you change midstream. The walls were green then terra cotta and that white trim was bugging me so everything is now Alabaster, top to bottom.....aahhhhh. You don't see the uneveness no more. I like flat finish on walls, I just don't like looking at sheen.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    You might want to get a sample of BM Chantilly Lace. It is a bright clean white and it can be helpful when picking or seeing different nuances in off whites. Are you familiar with www.samplize.com. ? Great way to do samples and easy to move around and assess in different light conditions. I have mine in a big ring 3 ring binder for easy reference and keeping them clean and organized.

  • 4 years ago

    I am glad you got the answer you were looking for. You know what gloss level you want.


    As for the color you are thinking that what is popular is best - what is hot!


    When you go in to buy a new car you may think "this is a great color" I need to own this! It doesn't have to match your house or go well with the scenery as you drive down the road.


    But when a woman goes into a cosmetics counter do you think she ever asks what the most popular color foundation, blush or lipstick is? Or does she ask what color foundation, blush or lipstick will look good with her skin tone, eye color and hair color?


    Interior design is much more like buying cosmetics than it is like buying a car. Everything has to work together.


    I just recently read a post where someone re-painted their home SW Canvas Tan after choosing SW Natural Linen. What she found was that Natural Linen had a flesh tone in her home with her flooring. I had the exact opposite experience. I helped my sister choose a wall color for her new assisted living residence. The apt they showed us was painted with Canvas Tan on the walls and they screamed GREEEN. Comparing colors with her flooring we found that Natural Linen was perfectly neutral. She just moved in in June and loves the wall color.


    I used Comfort Gray in my home in Southern California and loved the soft, blue green color. My flooring, furniture and décor is very similar to my last home, but I moved to Central Pennsylvania. The lighting here with all the overcast days made Comfort Gray feel dreary and much darker and more gray than the blue green that I saw in California. To get the same feeling I went with BM Quiet Moments, which is much lighter and cleaner.


    Whites are much trickier than the more saturated neutrals. The amount of color is so slight that you don't really see much difference when looking at a small sample, but by the time you paint a few hundred square feet those colors have multiplied and suddenly you see green or blue or yellow that you can't shake.


    Because white is so reflective you also have to consider your lighting. Direction of the sunlight, climate, even things like altitude and air pollution can impact the appearance of the color. Low e glass can cast a green glow on your walls, as can trees outside of your windows.


    I wish you the best of luck on your color journey.

  • 4 years ago

    BTW - the hot new white that I am seeing on posts and blogs is SW Cheviot - only available in the Emerald collection. It is a nice white, but it is also new and exclusive so it is getting a lot of attention.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Some people say the undertone of a paint color can't be defined because undertone is subjective and variable. Yes, exactly. My SW Alabaster window ledge in full California afternoon sun looks positively yellow/green to me and not pleasant. I've heard that from only one other comment here on Houzz. And no foliage on that side. It's only a couple hours a day though. You gotta be careful with whites, too.

  • 4 years ago

    I remember now...the other comment was someone painted their kitchen in SW Alabaster and said it looked like Mountain Dew. Hated it.