Software
Houzz Logo Print
ascarfpin

keep dark island or go light?

4 years ago

Our slightly off-white cabinets (have yellowed over the last several years) are being repainted in a couple of weeks, and I have an opportunity to decide if I want to make the island match, or keep the stand out dark walnut.

Comments (8)

  • 4 years ago

    What about a green? I think it would look beautiful with the creamy colored cabinets

  • 4 years ago

    It looks like you have two different countertops, too. I would consider painting your cabinets all the same color to make your kitchen more cohesive.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    its hard to see the island from the side.how big? what are the details? etc.......I'd keep it and probably swap the top for some butcher block as the top doesnt align with anything really. butcher block would coincide with the floor and the tone of the other counters. change the island top . any overhang allows one maybe two stools as well.

    Bird Street-Birmingham, Michigan · More Info


  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Hard to recommend without knowing more and can you take a picture from further back. Assume you are painting cabinets white, what is your dining table like, is your backsplash grey, what is the wall color.

    I’d lighten island just can’t recommend a color (you could even restain lighter) but thought the pictures below might help and also suggest new hardware.




  • 4 years ago

    I like dark wood islands, so I vote for leaving it alone. It would be difficult to lighten it without painting it. If you decide you do want to paint it, I like the idea of green.


    Kitchen · More Info


  • 4 years ago

    If you are not changing countertops then I would paint to match. But truthfully my preference would be to get all new tops the same and leave the walnut

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    IMO you either have 2 differnent colored cabinets and one counter or all the same cabinet color and a star island counter but not both. I have to say I would not spend money having those cabinets painted for 1000s of $$ they are dated and have you tried just changing the light bulbs to all LED 4000K. I would be spending the money on a proper hood for the range before painting at all.Is taht actually walnut or just a wood stained walnut color?

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Hi. My opinion is that different cabinets colors is trendy. It can work in very large kitchens, but is terrible in medium to smaller kitchens. Add to that, you have 2 different countertops. You don't want both different counter tops and different cabinet tones.


    Finally, you have white appliances. Unless you are planning to change them, it does not look good to have white appliances and then slightly off with cabinets.


    So, I would paint the cabinet colors the same.


    Conclusion: paint all cabinet colors the same, but not off-white. I'd need to see counter tones more, but something in gray or grey-green would work.