Black or bronze trim.
Navy is nice too.

I’d get a new door altogether.

Nice!! House!!! Lots of potential!!

I agree with previous comment, I would get new doors altogether, which would potentially update and refresh the appearance. I would replace lights with larger scaled lights. It is an attractive house, and just tweaking a few things will make it even better.

For the front door I would do black or a very dark green. I'm not feeling navy. To me the brick looks more orange than pink, but maybe it looks more pink in person. Even if you don't do all the work at one time, choose your new trim color before painting the front doors or getting new front doors. A bronze might work, taupe, or a less yellow cream. If you were to get new doors you could get a factory finished color which would hold up better than painting the existing doors. Agree that you need larger lights.

Our Work · More Info

Green Cliffs Road · More Info

Sewickley Farm Project · More Info

I'd go with forest green or navy for the doors. The current red clashes with the brick.

Any updates on how your house turned out @Kira Walters? We're trying to make similar decisions!