Software
Houzz Logo Print
ariel_dummer

Edge profile on slab cabinets?

3 years ago

We are getting ready to remodel the kitchen in our second home. I am semi-drawn to slab doors because of the simplicity and ease of cleaning. But every time I see them in person, no matter how high end, they scream doctor's office to me. I will try to attach pictures of my current house 20 year old slab drawers with 45 degree edges. (doors have a shaker look) How crazy / stupid would it be to have all wood batten style slab doors with a 45 degree edge profile to break up the super simplistic lines? One picture is our drawers in place. The other picture is two drawers stacked on each other to try to replicate full overlay with 45 degree edges. Thanks in advance for all input.



Comments (13)

  • 3 years ago

    I should have mentioned this will be stained - not painted. Currently leaning toward white oak in any sawn pattern. Lots yet to be determined.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Not sure what you mean by "all wood batten style slab doors." Have you already chosen a cabinet company? What are their options? Depending on the company and how custom they are, you may have a wide range of custom options. Also depends on your budget. Some cabinet lines have set options, and you really can't change much.

    But If you're going for simplicity and ease of cleaning, get full overlay with 90degree angle edges or inset drawers/doors.

    Ariel Dummer thanked Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
  • PRO
    3 years ago

    IMO a full overlay slab door no bevel on the edge is what I like IMO no inset doors if simplicity and ease of cleaning are whet you want. What you have now are neither .

    Ariel Dummer thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Diana I have a company on the short list that can do all these options. By all wood batten, I mean not banded plywood. Actual wood pieces glued together with batten boards on the back to keep them from twisting and warping. All pictures of any kind of slab doors that i can find online are just flat slabs with no edge profiles. Although this company lists edge profiles as available on the batten slab doors. I just wish I could find pictures somewhere of a slab door like that.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    You want slab doors on frameless cabinets. It's the frame that screams cheap!






    Ariel Dummer thanked BeverlyFLADeziner
  • PRO
    3 years ago

    I have done this type of profile only once. Apologies for the bad photo:

    I don't know if the overall effect improves anything from a frameless slab-door cabinet (ie, if it looks less like a doctor's office). This is slab rift-cut White Oak.

    I will caution you that a light-stained slab door will show a good amount of variation. You can see the color difference between the tall panel on the left and the drawers. Unless you select a laminate where the color is consistent, you will have some doors/drawers that are lighter or darker than others. I wouldn't move forward with a light-stained slab door (or one with an edge profile) unless you are okay with this.

    Ariel Dummer thanked Kristin Petro Interiors, Inc.
  • 3 years ago

    I don't think the edge treatment has anything to do with the battens on the back side does it? They just stick those on larger solid doors to reduce warping.


    Most of the ones pictured above look like veneered doors which won't do the edge you want as well as a solid door.



    I like the edges on your current doors and think they'd look quite nice in a full overlay setup. It's just a wee bit dressier than plain slabs. Nothing wrong with that! (And no, your current solid cherry cabinets don't look cheap in the photos shown. They are just built a way that is now a cheaper option.)

    Ariel Dummer thanked Fori
  • 3 years ago

    People keep saying "full overlay" on this thread, but what you want is "frameless construction" cabinets. Like what @BeverlyFLADeziner said in her comment above. I am just echoing for emphasis. Full overlay cabinets still reveal ¼ or ½ inch of the cabinet face between the doors. As opposed to frameless cabinets which are tightly aligned, showing none of the cabinet face. Fameless cabinets are the ones to buy if you want a clean look. They also have more internal space in the drawers and cabinets than framed full overlay.

    If slab doors "scream doctor's office" to you, then do not get them. That is strong wording you used, and it sounds like you will never be able to un-see "doctor's office". You are spending too much time thinking that a Shaker door will be hard to clean. Sometimes when planning a kitchen, you focus on things that actually are not true or are exaggerated. So rather than deal with "doctor's office", get simple Shaker, but still get frameless cabinets. There are Shaker door designs where the inside of the frame has a slight bevel to it, rather than a sharp edge, which makes dust harder to collect there.

    Ariel Dummer thanked RoyHobbs
  • 3 years ago

    Thank you everyone for your comments. All good ideas and things to consider. I'm starting think I am not going to be the slab door type. Time to move on. Thank you everyone!

  • 3 years ago

    I have solid wood slab doors (no battens) and there is no warping, cupping, etc. My windows are open often and I have zero humidity control in a poorly insulated 70-year old house.


    It depends on climate. Your local cabinet shops ought to have a pretty good idea what happens to wood in your area.


    I'd keep looking for inspiration pictures. I don't think you're asking for anything weird (and the statement about solid wood slabs being the worst choice is...well, often wrong). You should be able to find images of kitchens with "pillowed" slabs which is similar. Maybe that would help?

    Ariel Dummer thanked Fori
  • 3 years ago

    I have a modified version of what you were thinking for my studio drawers.


    Ariel Dummer thanked cpartist
  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Veneered slab doors are gorgous! Don’t let anyone talk you out of slab doors just because solid wood has issues with stability when humidity varies. Veneers are just perfect for the beautiful continuous grain patterns.






    Ariel Dummer thanked User