Software
Houzz Logo Print
tessa321

Staining Honey Shaker Cabinets - Help!

3 years ago

Hi - I recently bought a home and the previous owner had just bought all new cabinets but I just don't like the color. They are literally brand new so I just can't justify replacing them. My contractor says he can stain them the color I want but, so far, I haven't liked any of his samples.


I've attached some photos in different lights (and showing my flooring in one) but here is a link to the actual cabinets I have:

https://kovillecabinetry.com/honey-shaker


I'm looking for a warm walnut color to pull the warmth from my stone but the samples he's done look really blotchy to me and remind me of the cabinets I grew up with, lol.


I had considered painting but my overall design has more of a mid-century modern vibe and the cabinets will tie into a window bench and banquette so I just don't think a solid paint color will achieve the look I'm going for.


Any suggestions?!!?


Thank you!!




Comments (30)

  • 3 years ago

    The pics you posted— are those the samples of walnut look stain you want? I am looking at your link to the manufacturer website, and the cabinets shown there go well with your yellow floor. In The three pics you posted the cabinet and countertop just don’t look good with the floor at all. Do you have pics of your entire kitchen as it is now?

  • 3 years ago

    I'm thinking the colors aren't coming through well but the cabinets, as they are, look awful with my new white oak floors. I've attached my inspiration photo, my flooring with the cabinets that were here (a LOT that my contractor said he could stain like the ones he's building to complete the kitchen) and a pic mid-remodel.





  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I think the cabinets as they currently are have a Midcentury feel and would go well with a light counter (although maybe not with the gray veining, which is definitely very much of the last decade or so). Do you have any inspiration pics that would help us understand what you do and don't like?

    What is the piece of wood he did that stain on? That is, is it representative of stripping and staining your current cabinets, or is it an approximation? Because if the latter, then the final result with your actual cabinets could be more even or less!

    Are you confident about the layout of the kitchen and how it works for you? Because I'd hate to see you put thousands of dollars into changing the finishes, only to decide after a year that the function is really not a good match for your needs. Most people here suggest living with a new kitchen for a while before making major changes, for that reason, and sometimes you even find that the current look fits the house (and you) better than you think!

    Anyway, just some thoughts...

    Tessa H thanked acm
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Thank you, @User - I think the floor came through more yellow than it is in the picture but appreciate the opinion! @User - unfortunately they completely clash with our new flooring, @acm - yes, very confident! This is the 4th kitchen I've designed and the first time I've thought out the placement of every cabinet, shelf, drawer, etc. based on how we use our kitchen :-) It's almost done and we're VERY excited! The only thing I'm really questioning is the best direction to go with the cabinets. I'd much rather stain than paint if possible but, for our last kitchens we just primed and painted and they came out great - last one pictured below.


    Agree thestone is not mid-century - I guess my overall look is more modern but with some mid-century flair (if that makes sense!? lol.) They're just getting ready to stain the cabinets next week and I'm not feeling overly confident about them even though they've shown me a lot of similar cabinets they've stained and they look great but..... @User - I also keep seeing the muddiness so that worries me!! I can play it safe and paint but would really prefer the stained look this time.

  • 3 years ago

    I didn't read all the comments thoroughly, but I think the method you need is where they spray a water-based stain over the finish. Try asking the question in this FB page:

    (1) CABINET PAINTING & REFINISHING | Facebook

    (You will need to join first, of course.)

  • 3 years ago

    Thank you, @Mary Elizabeth!!! I probably made my question a lot more complicated than I had to, lol!

  • 3 years ago

    The issue is the grain on your existing cabinets will always come out like the samples they provided because it is what it is. It is not walnut or even rift cut white oak which would give you the look of your inspiration photos. I’d say the color they provided is close to your inspiration and would work w your floors but can you live w the blotchiness? I’d say you would be better off refacing if you want wood.

    Tessa H thanked thinkdesignlive
  • 3 years ago

    thank you @thinkdesignlive - I'm considering that. I'm actually having a lot of the cabinets built from scratch (so they will be wood) and only using the existing cabinets for some lowers and beneath my island. It will just be tricky to match the stain I guess.

  • 3 years ago

    I am sorry that you are not happy with the finish on your cabinetry. I grew up in a home built in 1957 and that was the color of the cabinetry. The home had white oak floors, too. Not as light as yours, because that wasn’t really the style then. I find it interesting to see how MCM is being interpreted in the 21st century. Good luck with your project….

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    I hate to tell you this but that color is very MCM your floors on the other hand are not. IMo to ruin a factory finish with some other finish is a bad choice. Since this is new to you place I woudl stop right now and wait until everything else is done before touching the cabinets.The counter is aslo not MCM I think you are trying to choose all the "in" items and not thinking of the style you are wanting to have.

  • 3 years ago

    Sorry to agree with everyone but re-staining a finished wood kitchen IS a nightmare. And that’s what you’re experiencing. You’re better off with refacing to a walnut color or painting a deep color as @Jan Moyer showed. I would vote for a deep navy blue to go with your countertop and existing floors.

    Your contractor did the best he could but since you’ve done 4 kitchens, you won’t be happy. Change the plan.

    Tessa H thanked RedRyder
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Guess I shouldn’t have said MCM - my bad. My style is what I like and a mix of different personal choices so I should probably refrain from giving it a specific name :-) I’ve done several very successful renos but have always played it safe with white cabinets so I just wanted to change it up this time. I'm now just second guessing my contractor’s advice (on the staining) even though he’s never steered me wrong before. @JAN MOYER - I LOVE those green cabinets - just have to build up a bit of courage as they're pretty bold for me :-) My stone is porcelain, though - not quartz, and will go to the ceiling with no uppers. I couldn’t do quartz bc my counter continues outside (below a flip out window) as a bar which isn’t possible / recommended with quartz. @User - aside from being a huge investment, I love my floors and countertops and those definitely aren’t going anywhere. My remaining cabinets (hidden coffee bar and pantry) as well as my banquette are custom and currently being built. Being that there is a LOT of surface space on the cabinetry / benches, I just want to make the right decision finish wise so need to decide on that (paint, stain, color) pretty soon. I'm only using about half the cabinets that were left by the prior owner (I bought mid-remodel but basically had to start over) and they are they are only being used for part of the kitchen - below and behind the island. In hindsight I should have just gotten rid of them and went all custom but I was trying to salvage some of the stuff in the house (I had to get rid of a lot) and trusted my contractor regarding the staining as he does a lot of carpentry work and I assumed he knew what he was talking about. Thank you all for the ideas, recommendations, and thinking points - I truly appreciate it!!

  • PRO
    3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I looooove!!! the green I just did for a client, ( very similar ) with pale oak island. Was a bit of a push, but ? They love it and as they say? No guts no glory. : )

    I'd post but we're still in a hot mess construction dust bowl.

    When you do this for a living and have produced white kitchens ( albeit gorgeous/every white on earth ) kitchens again and again and again? Though I'd die and go to heaven when this one went in.

  • 3 years ago

    @RedRyder - Deep navy is actually one of my top choices should I paint and have already sampled a few shades. Do you have a specific navy you've seen turn out well for cabinets? So far Hale Navy is my front runner :) Another dilemma is that the cabinets flow into the window bench which is the same style as the banquette that will be in the same area so there is just a lot of surface to cover and I'm not sure about mixing colors or finishes. This kitchen was my inspiration which is why I was leaning towards the stain: https://alyveljidesigns.com/residential/avd-bayview/

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Hale Navy is pretty fool proof. I've NOTHING against it.

    Butler off the kitchen below. But again...it isn't like it hasn't been done eighty ways to Sunday and back again.

    This stuff.... this sense of "gee, maybe it's time to move on ".......it happens to us.

    Doesn't make it a bad choice for you.

    Kitchen redo with butler · More Info


    Kitchen redo with butler · More Info


    Tessa H thanked JAN MOYER
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Thanks, @JAN MOYER - i just have a LOT of surface area with a pretty big hidden coffee bar, pantry, window bench, oversized banquette, etc. so I don't know if I have to do all the same color or ?!! Now you can see why I've always gone white, lol!

  • PRO
    3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    White IS a color. Ask yourself how many whites have been used in a kitchen? Ask yourself how many whites have turned to "sad yellow" when paired with baby blue walls by a novice lol

    Green is a color....neutral, actually. Just go look out a window and ask yourself if the green of the leaves are a clash with the blue of the sky!

    More rooms have died from a lack of guts than nearly almost any other "decision" .

    Green is great with white. With black too. I'd make the banquette and window seat something different, and think about a great fabric for cushion, that pulls in ....................................green.

    Maybe someone will faint from joy.

    You did type "LOVE those green cabinets you posted" ...so my eyesight didn't fail me - Right?

    Tessa H thanked JAN MOYER
  • 3 years ago

    @JAN MOYER - can you share the paint color so I can go grab a sample today? :)

  • PRO
    3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Of mine? I did a custom mix, Ben Moore......I could dig up the formula...I pray.

    Give me the weekend. : )

    Tessa H thanked JAN MOYER
  • 3 years ago

    @JAN MOYER - the green you just did for your client!? thanks :)

  • 3 years ago

    I would happily do the green kitchen that @Jan Moyer posted.

    Hale Navy is loved for a reason - people say it looks gorgeous. Both would be beautiful with white in a butler’s pantry or bar/desk/whatever area. The green would definitely be “bolder” only because it’s more unique, but I agree with Jan that green is neutral because it’s all around us all the time.

    Do a search for navy blue kitchens and green kitchens and see what you like best.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    " I'm actually having a lot of the cabinets built from scratch (so they will be wood) and only using the existing cabinets for some lowers and beneath my island. It will just be tricky to match the stain I guess. "

    Why not just go ahead and change them all since it seems like there are more new cabinets than old? . Sell the ones you have to help offset the cost. There is always a buyer for cabinets from a remodel.

    Good luck either way!

    Tessa H thanked Debbi Washburn
  • 3 years ago

    I used BM polo blue and love it! But the green is fabulous above and I think that shade or a darker forest green could look amazing with those floors of yours! Good luck I know how hard this is

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Tessa, while jan is looking for that green, marion over at miss mustard seed had a custom mix done to match her green (Boxwood) milk paint color. She painted this with it


    the recipe is in the bottom corner. You may have to play around with it a bit to get the tone you like (since every paint companies tints are different)

    the one jan showed you resemeble this shade. more of a forest green


    this one, Dunn Edwards Black Spruce

    is stunning!



    SW Pewter Green

    https://stylebyemilyhenderson.com/blog/portland-project-the-kitchen-remodel-reveal

    This is an Emily Henderson design.

    I love the color of this w/the wood and the countertop.


    But this paint color might not look exactly like this in your space. If you look at another example,




    It appears to have more gray to it. I guess it depends on your lighting and surrounding colors.

    The kitchen color in Emily's design almost looks like a Mediterranean Teal


    If you want a deeper shade, I love Jasper


    Lighter?


    here are some other blues if you want that route


    Tessa H thanked Beth H. :
  • 3 years ago

    Thanks, everyone!! @Julie Schmooley - do you happen to have a picture of your Polo Blue kitchen? Would love to see it! :)

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    @Beth H. : - thanks for all the great colors! I agree that Black Spruce is stunning and I love the Dard Hunter Green too - going to get samples of both! :-)

  • 3 years ago

    I’ll try and get another pic tomorrow when the sun is out!

  • 3 years ago

    @Julie Schmooley -The kitchen looks great! And the dog is adorable.

  • 3 years ago

    Thanks, @Julie Schmooley! I agree on both the kitchen and the matching pooch! 💙🐾