First that furniture is too small to have plioows since those pillows will need to removed for seating . What is the blue wall, what is the rest of the space like?

#2. The seating in #1 looks frumpy. The pillows and carpet are not playing well.

Agreed. Option 2

2

Neither - 2 big pillows like in the second photo, but without the solid blue one in the middle.

Everything selected is small. Small furniture, small rug, small pattern on pillows.

Make a STATEMENT with your selections.

You didn’t ask but…..

I would do #2 Sofa
With
#1 area rug
And one lumbar pillow in a different pattern than you have on #1 or #2

I like #2 because my style leans modern. If you are going for a casual cottage vibe I would go #1.

@craftlr cottage vibe

#2 I like more geometry.

Would you please tell me where to find the rug in #1? That would go beautifully with the new couch we have ordered.