Post a picture of the whole house and the paint colors so we dont have to look them all up.

I agree with the Alabaster... crisp and fresh.

Thanks Lyn - but you dont think the Natural Choice body and Alabaster trim will make it too close to each other in the color family? I was wondering if something like a Mega Greige or Agreeable Gray trim would be a better choice

IMO a darker trim color is inconsistent with the style of the house. If you want something a little lighter so there's more contrast, look at Pure White.

This was my initial thought

I will look at Pure White as well

Pure white will be too stark. Your choice is as different as I would go. The house is busy enough that it doesn't need much contrast.

Natural choice may be too dark and match the roof too much.  I would go lighter than alabaster for the body of the house.

Thank you all for your suggestions!

Just a plug that gutter color match the body color and not be highlighted with the trim color

No to trees shaped like a meatball on a stick.

We just repainted our home and it turned out beautiful. Try Sherman Williams Bison Beige DEC750 for the walls and Cocoe Powder DET631 for the trim. I then painted the front door Rainsong DET541. We also have the stone on our home and these colors are beautiful together.

Thanks - the colors look great. Will definitely check them out!