The wagon wheel light is 40” in diameter and would go in a living room (centered to room, with 6 pots as other lighting).

The pendants, of which there would be 2, have a diameter of 10” and would go over a 44” x 96” island in the kitchen. There would also be pot lights in the kitchen.

Both rooms are open to one another (see picture).

In an earlier post about my original lighting choices, it was suggested that I go with a different and bigger wagon wheel fixture and either drop the idea of pendants over the island OR go with task lighting with a black shade. That led me to these possibilities. I would probably use bullet style bulbs with a low wattage in the chandelier.

Looking for advice.