If that is falling down you have some major issues with the roof so get someone out to see what the exact issue is. Then come back for help with how it looks .

We are doing a large renovation on the house, including new roof, so that will be taken care of. I would love suggestions on the design though.

Just signing on to comment that completely flat roofs are almost always a bad idea - water MUST get away from the roof asap. If it doesn’t, it leads to roof failure.

Roofs must have at least a bit of pitch.

Are you now not moving the door to the other side of fireplace?

Perhaps you can post the current plan for the renovation, or just continue the discussions in one thread instead of three. Any project evolves, even before it starts, so it would be helpful to be able to follow along and know when things change, in order for the wise people here to offer suggestions.

This has already become a huge issues with duplicate posts on the same subject If possible remoe the ones with the fewest answers.

If you're re-roofing, I'd consider having the roof on the right side of the photo continue over the front entry instead of having that weird overlap it currently has. Then get heftier posts, if you need them.

Apologies for the multiple posts. I am not able to delete the old ones (been trying). I have requested they be deleted but no word yet.

Yep, the door is now staying put and not moving.

Most importantly you need to post a picture of the whole house…from the street , perhaps… just add it into the discussion… also be clear about what you are doing with the roofline

I'd strive to simplify the lines of the roof and overhang.