Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_624921883

Reno issue - how to resolve ?

3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago

Hi

I have been renovating with my second gc I got referred from old coworker after my original contractor abandoned the project

my new gc is trust worthy and I have respect for him

in our contract our basement staircase was included to finish and its written clearly

however his subtrade claims it was never included in quotation and needs to be charged

staircase is lets say about 4% cost of whole thing we singed for..

we do belive its genuine mistake of my gc

and he says he wont be paying and finish staircase out of his pocket

i do understand contract is contract and mistake happens and offered him we can pay 1/3 of cost

and he wont accept it

what should we do with this situation? any advice? my partner thinks we shouldnt panelize somones mistake and ask them to cover and at the end of day its our staircase and we should be paying for the 100% cost

its tacky situation and since my partner and I have different opinon its quite hard to resolve ..

Comments (12)

  • 3 years ago

    No caps, no punc, cannot read

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    His mistake, his responsibility.

    You shouldn't be dragged into disputes between a contractor and sub-contractor.

    If he paid less than expected, would he be sharing his windfall with you?

  • 3 years ago

    I would see if he would do it at cost and not add markup to it.  You paying the actual cost seems fair.

  • PRO
    3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    "i do understand contract is contract and mistake happens and offered him we can pay 1/3 of cost" OR...........

    "in our contract our basement staircase was included to finish and its written clearly "

    Both of these can't be true. It was in the contract to finished stair, or it was NOT?

    Read the first six words, of the first line above. Buy your staircase, and next time? Really READ your contract.

    Or....................




    get with the "reliable/ trustworthy" contractor/ gc and work something out. Even I am not understanding the issue.

  • 3 years ago

    Ask him to do it at cost since it was his mistake. Yes I personally would pay for the mistake as mistakes happen but making a profit from it? Nope.

  • 3 years ago

    Maybe you need to be trustworthy and if you want a staircase then pay for it.

  • 3 years ago

    I think the other commenters' idea about offering to pay cost is a good one. One third isn't the contractor's cost, that's why he's balking. If the sub is doing all the work related to this line item then the contractor's cost could be 80% of what he's quoting you. Stair work is expensive and it's a specialty (when done right). It's very finicky and involves a lot of math. :-) Did he counter offer when you offered 1/3 or did he just dig in for full price?

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Sorry but was this in or not in the contract ? That is where this ends . yes in the contract his dime not your dime wahtever you signed off on in the contract is what you get.

  • 3 years ago

    ...since my partner and I have different opin[i]on it[']s quite hard to resolve ..


    Try mediation. (Or marriage counseling.)

  • 3 years ago

    "in our contract our basement staircase was included to finish and its written clearly"

    This statement is not clear. Please quote directly from the contract.

    Is the current contract based on a "lump sum"? Is any of the work itemized?

    Describe in detail the difference in the level of finish that is in dispute.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    My contract specifies what is to be done including basement staircase

    its not itemized per cost but its pretty black and white matter is is included in my contract

    i will see if he will meet in half way or i will ask for trade work for my backsplash