Software
Houzz Logo Print
tatiane_rocha91

Prefab Quartz Full Backsplash vs Custom

3 years ago

We had water damage and are having to redo our kitchen. Because this caught us off guard and we knew nothing about dealing with insurance/ remodels / specific materials etc and we were super busy, we hired a contractor that has a restoration company. He’s been dealing with insurance on our behalf but sometimes this “preferred vendor” thing can feel like too much.
First flooring- he told us to go to floor and decor and I didn’t like anything there. I found another flooring from a smaller store recommended by a friend and the contractor insists I go look at SIDS carpet because they have good stuff there and I will be more likely to find flooring at or under the insurance approved budget. (I was going to pay 2 grand out of pocket but I was okay with it and he talks my husband into not paying 2k out of pocket and finding instead cheaper flooring.
Next counter top- he tells us to go to Kd Stone- I really dislike all their slabs and the store as a whole, (all prefabs) and then I go to Blackstone Granite & Marble Store and find an amazing custom quartz slab. When I tell him his answer is:

“I think both are good options and it really depends what you want to spend. The custom option will be more expensive than prefab. We have done a white quartz with gold veining from KD Store (preferred vendor) before. Did you specifically ask for that?“
Then he sends me pictures of samples from KD store preferred vendor.
This guy originally told us he recommended we switched the entire house flooring (even bedrooms on the same floor) to make everything consistent and with no transitions- now he’s telling us that doing a full backsplash with Prefab quartz is just as a good option as doing custom- depends how much we want to pay out of pocket.
Here’s a picture of the kitchen that got damaged- the pink granite and countertops will be replaced by Quartz. Leaning towards Calacatta Arno custom. It will cost $8K. Is prefab going to look just as fine as custom? Will we waste money by doing custom?

Blackstone Store says: they can give us prefab materials but doing us a favor because we have a relationship (friends business) however it’s not work that matches the quality they like to give their customers.

Comments (11)

  • PRO
    3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    You don't believe in Santa Claus , do you?

    You get what you pay for, The insurance company is not your designer. This contractor is not your designer.

    No pre fab is going to be as good as the slab/s you WANT , cut, polished and installed by a quality fabricator. An 8K quote for tops and splash same , custom, is not too out of line.

    No cheap floor will be the floor you want long term. .........unless you loved a cheap floor prior to the damage.

    Insurance rarely covers an "old " thing, replaced with a new/better thing. Pay up, get rid of the contractor, or better, boss him around, the way he is bossing you around.

    He's not your DESIGNER. He is the technician. He installs what you select as long as you are willing to pay for your selection......and you may have to devote more time to managing your "contractor"

    The only thing he was right about? Consistent flooring on the main level of the house. ONE FLOOR. Unless you love edge to edge carpet in bedrooms.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    IMO quartz is a poor choice no matter what route you take and of course can't really be good for a backsplash behind a range or cooktop. IMO the materials are your job to look at and choose his job is to install your choices. BTW yo should be dealing with the insurance company. Yes the same floor everywhere but the insurance might not pay for it all. Where is the carpet going ? IMO no wall to wall carpet .

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Your layout appears to lend itself to prefabricated slabs. I can't see big savings with prefabricated.

  • 3 years ago

    Patrícia, why do you think Quartz isn’t a good choice and what do you think would be a better choice? Thank you!

  • 3 years ago

    and for sure there won’t be carpet, insurance approved continuous flooring, going with LVP :)

  • PRO
    3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Patricia HATES quartz, Despises garbage disposal, and also pull out trash/recycle. She is passionate about 4000k led lighting, just ask : ). To be clear, quartz IS engineered stone. It is best when veining is very subtle....Capital S. and yes, it can make a beautiful kitchen when well chosen.

    There are many surfaces...Granite, Quartzite, Soap stone,, marble...that come from the earth. Mother nature made all. They all can make a beautiful kitchen too.

    Make sure that LVP is 20ml. : )

  • 3 years ago

    Okay where do I find this info on the LVP? the flooring is Tecsun great barrier. Can’t find out if it’s 20ml.

  • 3 years ago

    never mind I found the info :) we are good phew !

  • 3 years ago

    Ask @Joseph Corlett, LLC if quartz is an appropriate material for use as a backsplash. It has been installed in my two kitchens for over twenty years without a problem, including behind the range. I contacted both Cambria and the range manufacturers, both of whom said that, when installed within their specifications, there should be no issues. I understand that there have been some reports of scorching behind cooktops. I can put my hand on the quartz behind the range with the oven or burners on full blast, and its barely warm.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Your gas cooktop is close to the backsplash. Induction will propduce much less of the waste heat that can be a problem. Bosch is a good option. A stone to look at is Taj Mahal quartzite.

  • 3 years ago

    Patricia is also not a fan of farmhouse sinks or shower niches.