Software
Houzz Logo Print
sheree_orvets90

Recommended Water Filtration System

3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago

New Calacatta Marble on kitchen countertops has hard water spots after 1st week of installation!

What water filtration system will work best to eliminate calcium & magnesium Water Softener or

Reverse Osmosis? I'm hearing potassium chloride would work better than sodium but really

pricey.

Comments (8)

  • 3 years ago

    Thank You really great advice!

  • 3 years ago

    You simply need a water softener in order to solve the spotting problem. This can be an $800 unit - an expensive unit will not make the water more soft.


    Often the cold water in the kitchen is not softened - because some people don't like the taste or are on sodium restricted diets. Keep in mind that if you don't soften the cold, you will still have spots... just not as bad.


    The best answer is to soften the hot and cold, and then have an unsoftened drinking water line run - and put a decent carbon filter on it.

  • 3 years ago

    Thanks Jake will you weigh in on Reverse Osmosis and using salt Vs potassium in a water softener? A plumber friend who has marble is using the NuevoH2O system. I've read horrible views and dubious about the citric acid.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    R/O, if you use it, is going to be something that you use to filter your drinking water only. Within the context of residential water filtering, it makes very small amounts of filtered water (a few gallons a day) and wastes a lot of water to do it. You aren't going to use R/O as a whole house water filter that would include your hot water, for example. R/O water is also aggressive to metal - so any plumbing that touches R/O is typically plastic.

    You use an R/O filter to remove problem chemicals that can't be removed by other means - nitrates, lead, and a few others. If you don't have that issue, you don't need R/O.

    You simply need a water softener if you are having an issue with hard water spots.

    Both sodium chloride and potassium chloride will soften your water (soft water is defined by <1 grain of hardness per gallon).

    Potassium costs about 5x a bag ($30 for 40#) as sodium ($6 for 40#) AND it takes much more Potassium to accomplish the same thing. That makes potassium a VERY expensive way to soften water.

    For the most part, you see people using potassium chloride instead of sodium chloride because they are on a sodium restricted diet. The reality is that soft water adds very little extra sodium to the diet (less than a glass of milk, or slice of bread). And if you use carbon filtered but not softened water in a drinking water faucet in the kitchen, you really remove that argument altogether.

    Sheree Orvets thanked Jake The Wonderdog
  • 3 years ago

    Try this from Costco. If it doesn't work for you return it. I've heard good things about the device. I've installed one but haven't completed my renovation to comment on its effectiveness since I'm in a rental until I'd done.



    Sheree Orvets thanked Paul F.
  • 3 years ago

    Thx Jake for the advice and currently looking into a basic water softener. Don't trust the new cartridge systems but would of liked to avoid dealing with maintaining & cleaning a brine tank. Appreciate your input!!

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    My municipal water is 23 grains of hardness - which is very hard.


    I've had my water softener for 7 years and all I've had to do is put salt in it. The resin will last 10-15 years and at that point I can decide if I want to re-bed it or just start over. I'm sure that I could re-bed the resin and be good for another 10 years.


    I bought it on Amazon and installed it myself. Best $600 I've spent.


    With the softener, all of my fixtures stay cleaner, my dishes come out of dishwasher without a film and I use less soap. Clothes and skin feel better also. It also reduces maintenance on my tankless water heater.


    I put a carbon filter on the cold drinking water in the Kitchen and the ice maker. When I redo the kitchen I'll have a drinking water faucet. The water from that filter tastes great - and it's cleaning up a lot of "stuff" that I'd rather not have in my water. The filter lasts 2 years and costs $100 to replace.