Cute, Federal style vibe and my suggestions are to paint the vinyl S W Anonymous: paint all the trim the same color which will help disguise the off side windows; paint the front door trim the same, too.

Easy, vinyl, all trim, just one color.

I don't care for a storm door and exterior door painted two different colors and I think it would make a huge difference if you invested in a new, well insulated, energy-efficient exterior door and have no storm. For the front door go with S W Urban Bronze...try it with a gloss finish...it will show beautifully.

Then purchase two new sconces. Not too small and stay with a Federal style and do a dark bronze on the brick.

I just read a little blurb, the sconce in the store looks like the right size, but it isn't. When looking from the curb that sconce will look half its size. I never knew that...makes sense, though.

I like this paneled front door style for your house.

I just recently painted my house with SW Anonymous, it is a nice color and goes well with lots of different shades of brick. We used Urbane Bronze for the accents. I could see this working on your house and I agree its giving Federal vibes, I like the red brick!

Agree with the above advice on the outdoor lighting, go a bit bigger. We recently replaced our outdoor fixtures and they are slightly larger than what was on the house prior and it looks much better. I think a dark finish (black or bronze) on the outdoor lighting would pop against the red brick and complement a darker color scheme like Anonymous/Urbane bronze.

Some option