IMO the house will never be modern no matter what color you paint it This is my fave color with brick only becuase it works with brick and also keeps all the surfases the same to harmonize the elemnets for a bit simpler look at least Remove the shutters too I think this look would be a much better one than what you are planning

You did not answer my question at all. Your comments did not help.

Agree with Lyn that one color will have a more modern look - assuming you are removing the shutters as well?

Yes, the shutters were removed. That is an older picture. I also plan to do a modern horizonal front porch, all stained wood. Thanks for the help!

What is the siding material currently? Soffit and fascia as well? If they are vinyl no black or real deep colors.

The siding is hardiboard. The soffit and fascia are both wood.