Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_617928998

White Kitchen Renovation - Advice

3 years ago

Hi all! I’m new here but wanted to ask for some advice and see how it goes! I appreciate any input.

I’ve been racking my brain for a few months trying to get unstuck with some design decisions in our kitchen renovation but feeling stuck. I’ve tried hiring a designer but many don’t want to take on a project this small.

We recently replaced our kitchen cabinets but had to keep the same foot print. I love the cabinets & color but once the counters went in, I realized how wrong I was about my selection. I feel like the two different shades of white clash and I’m not a fan of the grey pattern.

Should we keep the counters and find a backsplash that ties them together? Change the hardware color? Or replace the counters to something that works better?

Thank you for any input!

Comments (14)

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    As a designer that specializes in kitchen design. The colors are a good match but you have incorrect contrast to your kitchen.


    I can give you my feedback with some options one being more cost effective and one that will cost more but will yield better results.


    Option 1 (Cost effective)

    Find a backsplash that pops. I'd recommend a mosaic tiles that have metal or at least a second color to them to divert away from the countertop that has too much mini veins in them. Add under cabinet lighting to brighten up the backsplash and countertop with lighting.


    Option 2 : This would give a more dramatic improvements

    Replace countertop that has less veins but larger veins(not too large)

    Stick with a mosaic backsplash

    Change all lighting in the area ( you seem to adding rustic hardware and fixtures with a transitional kitchen)


    For future references. When remodeling a kitchen please do not flush the cabinets with the window edges. This is one of my largest pet peeves in kitchen remodels. If you still need assistance you can reach out to me as I offer nationwide virtual design service.


  • 3 years ago

    Because it's a photo, and the lighting varies, I'm unsure if the top cabinets and the lowers are different colors or if it's the photo. Assuming it's the photo, the cabinets look yellow against the stone in the upper photo, yes? but in the lower photo they look great. Make sure your eye is not getting fooled by the primer white on the backsplash.

    The counters are so pretty and are *expensive*, I think it would be much easier to find another shade of white or color that you like equally well. What are you doing with your backsplash? Are you going to gamble on finding a third white that matches, or do something else?

  • 3 years ago

    BTW, there are color consultants on line, don't know if I can mention names but they may be a good resource for you.


  • 3 years ago

    Hi! Thank you for your feedback, greatly appreciated! I was worried about that with the counters - that replacing them all together would be the best option. For the window, I completely agree! It was supposed to have room for window casing but it was a miscommunication with our cabinet maker, as his rendering showed that there was room for window casing but he claimed we never spoke about it. Sadly it was one of the things I didn’t fight hard enough for him to fix.

  • 3 years ago

    Hi Jenny, thanks for weighing in. All of the cabinets & trim are painted the same color - BM Swiss Coffee. However, the natural lighting in our house seems to make it look like a different shade every which way you look. I was hoping for a classic, subway tile backsplash but I do think it’s too risky introducing another shade of white. I’ll look into the color consultation, that’s a great idea.

  • 3 years ago

    I think your kitchen is very pretty. Have you tried different lighting/lightbulbs?

    What if you did a backsplash with varied shades of whites and some brass to tie it all together?




  • 3 years ago

    Is it an option to do the countertop material as your backsplash? Here’s a picture of a warm/cool mix. Or else a subway tile in a pretty color? I think your kitchen is really nice! I love your pendants and all the texture.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Gorgeous kitchen!

    I specialize in Kitchen & Bath Design and agree with @jlc712 

    I'd also recommend trying out a backsplash that is a mosaic and is multi-colored.  The suggestion of finding one's with beige and creams was smart.

    In addition, if the natural light in your space is causing this issue, have you considered changing out the lights on your recessed to see if when you turn the lights that would help even the score.

    Look for a Kelvin value that is closer to natural light, 5500-6500, I'd stick around the 4k range as you don't want it too light.  Also, hopefully your lights are all on dimmers as well.

    If you have any additional questions feel free to shoot me and message.  I'm happy to help.

  • 3 years ago

    I think your kitchen looks great and many people would love to have it! I love those pendants. What are your counters? I would definitely try to find a backsplash that ties everything together before replacing the counters.


    Do a search on here for Cloe white tiles. There is a lot of color variation in the mix of tiles (from white to beige to gray) and it goes with just about anything.


    I'm sure the Pros will chime in and give some more suggestions. Good luck with your decision!

  • 3 years ago

    Thanks all! I appreciate it. I will check on the lighting/light bulbs - maybe that will
    Help reduce the yellowing towards the uppers. and love the idea of a colored subway tile or something that has the cream & gold combination. I’ll check on the Cloe white tiles too!

  • 3 years ago

    I know colors are hard to communicate in photographs, but when I first saw the pictures of your kitchen, I thought “wow! Nailed it.” I think as kitchen design trends return to timeless and more historically authentic looks, I have seen many cream based cabinets and natural stone countertops that have more of a gray veining. It looks like you achieved this while avoiding many trappings of trendiness.


    Some resources you may be familiar with but may also encourage you would be

    -W Design Collective (WDC)

    -Unique Kitchens and Baths (UKB)

    -Caroline Levenson Designs

    -Leanne Ford in her recent Pittsburg home.


    WDC and UKB both offer online consultations by the hour if you’re looking for some professional help.


    Some tile sources that offer soft, vintage white and gray tiles:


    -Lancaster Vanilla 3x6 Polished Ceramic Wall Tile


    -Mercury Mosaics 11 Deco White 3"x6" Subway Tile | Overstock (see patticakewagner bathroom remodel)


    -Fireclay Tile (many soft whites and off whites to choose from)


    -Marlborough Tile (out of England, offers many vintage looking and handmade tiles)


    -HDM's Glazed Ceramic 3" x 6" ($14.00/sf) Subway Tile Collection in Vintage Warm White


    I’ve recently hired two designers for my own kitchen and both have advised me to go with a backsplash that compliments the cabinets with a slightly lighter grout. Everyone is different, but I don’t want a backsplash being what draws people’s attention when they walk in the room.


    I’m not a designer, and I’m sure some Pros will weigh in with much more helpful input, but I think what you’ve done is timeless and lovely. I am sorry you’re disappointed! I do think installations of this scale can often feel shocking. I think as you live with it, you’ll grow to love it. I sure do!

  • 3 years ago

    Again, I am not a professional. But I have never seen a bold backsplash color, nor a mosaic backsplash that has not ended up dating a Kitchen within 5-10 years. Of course, it’s what you love that matters most! But I think these kitchens nail the backsplash/countertop/cabinet combo.






  • 3 years ago

    Would you mind sharing the dimensions of your kitchen? Mine has a similar walkway through it and I’m very inspired By yours!

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    All overused trendy materials become dated. It doesn't matter if they are classic. How materials are paired together is what screams dated. Subway tile is/will become dated when it is paired with white on white on white.

    I remember when I was building a home in 2000, the designer told me not to do white cabinets. Nobody wants them. In 2006, designers told me cherry and travertine are classic and won't date your home. Well..... those statements didn't age well.

    I would recommend looking at some of the m osaic tiles suggested above. Chose something you love. Your kitchen will look beautiful.