I agree with rebunky; two different sizes will look great. So does your new kitchen!

agree w/rebunky as well.

Yep.

Either of the 2 options will work and look good. Which do you like best?

We decided on the 2 different sizes. Thank you all for your help!

Now that the pulls are in I think I chose too large all together.  Really beating myself up over this. I think I should have done 7" on the 22" and 24" cabinets,  and 9.5" on the 33". My husband says it's great how it is, that smaller would be too small, but I can't help thinking I made a mistake.

This was the photo I meant to post.

I think they look perfect

I also think they look perfect! Beautiful kitchen!

I think they are balanced and in proportion to the cabinets. I think it's just a big change from seeing the cabinets with no pulls. You may also be used to seeing a lot of "every cabinet has a 4" pull" look, but I think yours is much more sophisticated.

They look amazing! Kitchen is fabulous,

They look PERFECT

Thank you everyone.  Hardware has been the most difficult piece for me. There were so many options and I'm still having doubts, even about the brass finish. Hopefully with time, I let it go and move on.

Either option would work, and certainly your chosen option looks great! Feel free to love it!

@MGdecor - I think that when your kitchen is in this stage - inbetween - it's very easy to obsess over the details and wonder if you made the right choice. From our perspective, it's gorgeous.