Get samples of the cladding from each dealer.

Do you mean just the front door ? I agree get smaples from each and I rarely get a front door from a window place so this is not unusual .

Marvin is expensive for a reason, and S/P is inexpensive for a reason. Colors will not match and the quality will not be anywhere near close either. S/P is not a quality product. For more thoughts on I would post this on the Windows subforum.

Thanks all - Do you know anything xabout WeatherShield? was suggested as less expensive option than JellWen…

Both bottom of the barrel builder grade windows.