I'd go with a warm cream for both siding and stucco with a medium blue for the shutters. It will look great!

Thanks, those are the colors I was leading towards too.

Gorgeous home...what year was it built?

I wouldn't paint the stucco. As the long time owner of a 1913 stucco house, it is virtually maintenance free and it goes with the build. You already have the perfect shutters (and windows, correctly, without), consider just painting th clapboard in the same color as the stucco. Do it it in "soft gloss" exterior from B.M. which will highlight the different textures.