Software
Houzz Logo Print
shannon_soehner

Ideas for a rustic feel after siding update?

2 years ago

We have to replace the 43-year-old cedar siding on our lake home due to poor condition. We will be updating with the 7" lap siding from Ascend in the Deep Moss green color and some Alside Auburn Weathered shakes on the garage and gables. We will be keeping the roof and dark brown garage doors and trim. As this is on a lake, we hope to maintain the rustic vibe. Any other suggestions of architectural features or things we could change or add to maintain the rustic charm? Maybe corbels? I wish we could just replace the cedar, but it is too expensive and not practical for us.


Original 43 year old Cedar 8" siding




New siding mock design


Comments (14)

  • 2 years ago

    I do not think you need to add anything after the siding " to maintain the rustic vibe ". I would reevaluate this after the siding is installed but the house design and setting will have more to do with the look than fluff.

  • 2 years ago

    Corbels aren't rustic and won't go with your house. I do note the window trim and door are very similar to the color of the house. It will look a lot better with a contrast. The cedar is gorgeous.

  • 2 years ago


    Our most recent intrusion that had to be patched...

  • 2 years ago

    Looks like a woodpecker got to it. My brother had this issue with a house too. Were you planning on replacing your garage doors?

    Shannon S thanked kandrewspa
  • 2 years ago

    No, we were not planning to change the dark brown garage doors at this point, and the roof is only about 7 years old, so we plan to keep it for now. We have about 15 small woodpecker holes, but none of them are like this 4" one!

  • 2 years ago

    I would replace the siding with the same pattern/layout. That means all one color, no shakes, no separating the gables with a different material. I would even recreate the diagonals.


    The better plan would be to replace just the boards with holes and clean the rest. Is that going to be 15 pieces of siding? Not a big deal. The new stuff you are considering won't last nearly as long and won't be as repairable.


    Your plan risks turning a charming rustic (but a bit sophisticated) home into a couple boring plastic-looking boxes.

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    A good carpenter will know how to replace the damaged boards. Clean the cedar and you're done with enough money in your pocket to address the landscaping and the entry canopy.



    If the woodpeckers are going after insects that is because the cedar planks are soiled enough to attract insects

    Shannon S thanked BeverlyFLADeziner
  • 2 years ago

    What sticks out to me is the concrete driveway and foundation/basement area. Consider staining it so it blends more with the surroundings and isn't so stark white.

  • 2 years ago

    That's helpful feedback. Thank you!

  • 2 years ago

    The experts are giving you some good advice about not doing what you are planning to do. The green moss siding is a mistake.

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    The house is not rustic either is the fence or the deck railing so not sure what you are trying to do. I have to agree green siding does not work in my head. The cedar is proably not damged so much it needs replacement so follow some of the advice here before going the all new .

  • 2 years ago

    That cedar is like gold! Do what you can to repair/clean/replace where needed and try to keep it.

  • 2 years ago

    I’m not a pro but I do agree that taking this look and replacing it with green siding may lead to regret. Please heed Beverly’s suggestions.