Waht is on the floor now? It seems you are shoing different floors already in the space. From the ones you show I would go with the Pecan I do have to say I dislike oak so it is a hard sell for me always.

Our current floor is having issues with buckling and gaps. We are having to replace it after only 1 year 😢

Of those, I would choose the middle. While I prefer a lighter floor, the pecan looks like it might be too stripey.

The middle looks closest to what you have and should match your furnishings.

@millworkman the flooring issues have been evaluated by our contractor. The subcontractor didn’t put down a moisture barrier and he also installed the flooring under cabinets which is a big no-no because it can’t expand and contract like it needs to. Current floor is a luxury vinyl lank SPC.

Your showing pictures next to paint colors.

Do you have any other wood in the space? Furniture, cabinets? What is the color of your upholstered furniture?

My assessment of the three you have sampled next to the wall colors you are showing I find the Sunbathed Pecan (left) is too yellow and Trinket Oak (right) is a bit green next to the bluer gray and doesn't have enough contrast against greige wall color. That leaves Natural Bark Oak (Center) as the best choice of the three.

Here’s a picture showing our white cabinets (same white cabinets throughout great room & kitchen). We do have very dark beams & mantle, but not willing to go that dark for the floors. The natural bark oak sample is propped up against the fireplace to show how it mixes with the mantle, cabinets, stone.

Of the ones shown, I'd go with the middle one.

I am really liking the Natural Bark Oak with the fireplace and the dark beams.

Is your flooring install a done deal? Did you order a box of planks first to get a better view of what the flooring looks like? We’re having to replace most of our house flooring because of a leak & the continous flooring in house is no longer available. I uploaded pics & used Mohawks RevWood visualizer - wow - what I saw bore no resemblance to the sample in our house. Even the pics I took with sample next to various things in our house looked different than the sample. We hope the box of planks helps us with our choice. We’re looking at Sun Dried Oak - a RevWood Plus selection.