no, but neither is your light fixture... But, if you like it, use it.

I would replace both the mirror and light fixture.

BTW…. I don’t want farmhouse style.

it's more Shabby Chic.

I like it. I don't think it's farmhouse. But it doesn't fit with the chandelier which is more glam.

This style of mirror adapts to many looks, depending on what it is paired with.

If you feel it could too busy, there are variations.

The biggest consideration is that its size doesn’t overwhelm the table.

So, do you think it will look better this one?

Looks to me to be a great compliment. The V in the mirror at the top matches the supports in the table.

Thanks for your comments, I was kind of concerned about the design. I was thinking that the simple one looks better than the first one. My husband’s favorite is the first option.

Personally I would chose the simple one. You have a lot going on with your ceiling light and it would be a shame to detract from that! Good luck.

There is no right or wrong and perhaps look for a happy medium. Try searching on Pinterest for ”black arched mirror over table” to help with your decision. You may end up not liking the look at all, so be sure it can be returned easily. How the table is accessorized is really important so keep that in mind.

Maybe consider round or silver, both would work well with your chandelier. An added quandry lol.

You have an arch already. Maybe a different shape would look good.