Software
Houzz Logo Print
af81ad12

Quartzite counters - yay or nay?

2 years ago

I’m in the thick of countertop shopping for our kitchen renovation, and thoroughly confused! I love the qualities and durability of granite, but cannot find a type I love. Quartz is okay, but I haven’t found the perfect one yet either. Then I saw Taj Mahal quartzite and I can’t get it out of my mind. It’s GORGEOUS!

But… I’m hearing and reading mixed reviews about it. Is it more prone to chipping? Is honed more durable than polished? Is it way more expensive than granite and quartz?

Comments (10)

  • 2 years ago

    The short answer: yes, TM is expensive (which is a relative term….to me it is, to others not; we paid $200/sf for ours) , but I’m sure there are more expensive slabs…the sky’s the limit. It does chip more easily than quartz (we were told the harder the stone, the more prone to chipping it is), but can also be repaired fairly easily. We originally wanted leathered or honed TM, but the lighter slabs we were after did not come in anything but polished. Our research showed that having a polished slab adds an extra layer of protection, and honing a polished slab would also make it darker. We wanted the lighter TM, so we ended up going with polished. Once sealed it’s super easy to clean….no etching or staining etc. We love our counters and don’t regret our choice. Good luck!

  • 2 years ago

    Thank you coray. This is very helpful.

  • 2 years ago

    We put in honed Taj about 18 months ago, and I love it so much. I did have to put in many hours of searching to find good slabs because the majority were polished, and I didn't want that. I would have been happy with honed or leathered. It has a little bit of texture to it which I love. It's very low maintenance. My favorite part of the kitchen! If you go shopping, be aware of slabs that have lots of filler; I think the stone is prone to fissures that get filled and it's not the best look.

  • 2 years ago

    stiley, thank you. I wasn’t aware of the filler. How do you know if there is filler in a slab?

  • 2 years ago

    I could see it when looking closely. And run your hands over it and it feels different. They're usually priced lower too. Slab shopping can be a racket and I learned to ask lots of questions at different places. Some people were more straightforward than others, but one sales guy pointed out the filler to me and then it was easy to spot. But since that stone is so popular right now, I made it practically my full-time job for about four months to find the perfect slabs. In the end, I got mine because I had visited with a sales woman at a slab place, and she called right when they got a new shipment in.

  • 2 years ago

    Taj Mahal is one of the quartzites that I think has a 99.9% satisfaction rating! I have been participating here for many years and only remember one poster with issues.

    Many of the white/gray quartzites seem to be prone to staining. Some of them might just be mislabeled marble and some are hard like quartzite, but still porous. This is why testing slabs, at the slab yard, with some easy tests is recommended. Buyer beware.

    I have shopped for Taj Mahal for 2 kitchens. The last time was at the end of 2020 so inventory was limited. I was happy I found the 3 slabs I needed, but they were a bit less perfect than the slabs I had bough for the first kitchen.

    Here is a photo of a small section with filler. If they are done well, you don't really notice unless you are looking for it. This one is in the middle of my island.


  • 2 years ago

    I personally prefer Taj Mahal to be in a polished finish. The stone has beautiful translucence, sparkle, and depths like looking into deep water. Those things are muted or even gone when the stone is honed or leathered. I advise you to see slabs in both finishes to see which you prefer.

    You also need to have a good fabricator, and rely on their expertise. For a previous kitchen I chose a granite slab I loved. When the fabricator went to the stoneyard to pick it up, he refused it because he saw fissures in that slab that could create problems going forward. I chose another slab - the same exact granite - that did not have fissures. You won't have the expertise that a good fabricator has. Having said that, we see lots of tales of woe on this forum about bad fabricators who don't know what they are doing, and/or use poor tools that aren't sharp enough or that they don't understand, and end up messing up the slab. So be careful in your choice of fabricator.

    The choice of fabricator is as important or maybe more important than the choice of slab.

  • 2 years ago

    I would warn you against doing an ogee (or double ogee) edge on your countertop, no matter what stone you choose. My first granite countertop had an ogee edge and definitely chipped easily. My current kitchen has just a rounded edge and has never chipped.

    I also love a polished stone. When they’re wiped clean with a microfiber cloth, they really shine and make the stone look amazing. But if you think you like honed, first look at a kitchen with a Taj honed countertop. If you like the look, then make sure to find a good stone person to work with. Getting the templating right is critical.

  • 2 years ago

    The fissure/filler issue Stiley mentioned was the reason we ended up with 2 polished slabs instead of leathered or honed. For some reason (and this might have been just in our area, at that time) all leathered or honed slabs were really dark, gray, had lots of fillers etc…they definitely seemed like ”2nd or 3rd class” slabs and not what we wanted. I recommend you take your time during your search.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    I have the exact color cabinets in my house and wanted taj mahal but i need a few slabs and the taj in my area is not attractive. you found a pretty one! love it!


    the filler in the slabs i saw were huge veins running through it… not pretty. i wouldnt even notice the filler in chispa’s photo.