Software
Houzz Logo Print
aivalotis1

Help ID a new seedling

Last fall I collected some seed from my Silene Regia and Lobelia cardinalis plants and spread the seed in some large bare dirt containers filled with a mixture of potting and purchased top soil. Had fairly good germination and just finished separating the plants into smaller containers. Very few weed plants emerged but did have quite a few of one, I'm not sure what it is.


Silene regia - consistent with my existing plants




Lobelia cardinalis - consistent with my existing ones




The unknown - I believe all of these to be the same









Comments (15)

  • 2 years ago

    The second picture of the unknown appears to have flowers or calyxes at leaf axils in a couple of spots. Looks weedy to me.

  • 2 years ago

    Is picture 2 just one plant? Looks like a dandelion with another small seedling in the center.

  • 2 years ago

    The picture I mention is below " the unknown" and number 2 photo.

  • 2 years ago

    Triodanis perfoliata???

  • 2 years ago

    callirhoe123, pretty sure it's one plant and pretty sure it's a cardinal flower, but you are having me second guess! Seedlings are like a box of chocolates ! Time will tell.

    floraluk2, you may be right, and I have added that plant to my landscape. It did enter my mind and decided to pot them instead of discarding. Glad I did, I will find them a home.

    Thanks to all

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    Plant in pic 2 appears to have rough leaves, so not Taraxacum. You could test by tearing a leaf. T. Would have milky sap.

  • 2 years ago

    No milky sap

  • last year

    Old Forester. Maybe Youngia japonica for number 2? For the other compare with Kickxia spuria. The Kickxia must be moving south. This might be a new record, if it is Kickxia. I can report it to the Flora. Kickxia spuria is not native. It has a very interesting flower. It's in Plantaginaceae.

  • last year

    Jay, you made me do some deep thinking to remember those plants. If I remember correctly, pic 1, was indeed Silene Regia. Picture #2 was not Cardinal flower, in fact I had no Lobelia seeds germinate. The rest were Triodanis perfoliata, I think. What was puzzling is I did have numerous seedlings that as best as I could identify turned out to be Silene spinescens. Cant remember if pic 2 was one of them. Have no idea where those seeds would have come from.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    #1 is Silene regia. I dont think #2 is Silene spinescens. I don't see any north American observations for Silene spinescens. I cant even find a photo of Silene spinescens leaves. I still think its Youngia japonica or another species in the Asteracese Chicory tribe. I still think Kickxia spuria is a better match thsn Triodanis perfoliatus because the leaves arent perfoliate or heavily clasping, and the stems have more pubescence than Triodanis perfoliatus stems.

  • last year

    I kept all the seedlings until they bloomed. The seedlings were definitely Triadanis. Pic 2 bloomed and was not Youngia japonica. Didn't keep any pics of the bloom but it matched Silene spinescens. Thanks for the feedback.

  • last year
    last modified: last year
    1. Old Forester, where did the Silene spinescens come from? It's not listed in Weakley's Flora of the Southeastern United States, there are no seeds or plants available for it online. There isn't a simgle observation for it in North America?It's a subshrub that grows in arid conditions in southeastern Greece? The flimsy rosette doesn't seem to match a xeric subshrub? Im going to get a second opinion about the Triodanis also. The leaves are definately not perfoliate.



    Silene spinescens

  • last year

    Yes, it is Triodanis perfoliata. I didn't know the petioles were so variable, so,chock up another one for floral.😒

  • last year

    I could not identify the Silene even after it bloomed, never seen anything like it. A friend of mine has a plant identifier app that I have tested many many times, it's quite accurate. The app called it Silene spinescens. Did some online research and it matched. Have no idea where the seed came from. I had around a dozen of the seedlings. They perished right after they bloomed.