Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_890130790

Quartzsite versus Quartz Kitchen Countertops

2 years ago

Hello everyone,
Where are in the process of a DIY kitchen remodel. It has been going very slow and steady. It is now time to select countertops. I thought I wanted white quartz countertops countertops, but the more I have searched for them the less I like the way they look. I have fallen in love with quartzite. As most of you know it's more expensive and more expensive to have installed. After reading many comments about quartzite I am beginning to question whether or not it is as durable as the people selling it say it is. From what I have gathered It sounds like a lot of the problems are in the sealing or lack of sealing. One article I came across that I found very interesting was that the edges that have been cut and the holes that have been cut for the faucet all also need to be sealed prior to installation. I thought that this made a lot of sense and might help other people that are having issues with it staining on the edges and around the faucet. I appreciate any information anyone has on this subject. Thank you for taking the time to read my post.

Comments (16)

  • 2 years ago

    Another problem is that a lot of stones sold as "quartzites" are essentially marbles, so they will weather and age (and possibly stain and patina) like marbles will, sealant or not.

  • 2 years ago

    Specific types of quartzite are uber durable - Taj Mahal, Madre Perla etc - you have to do your research and make sure you know what to buy and also make sure the slabs you’re buying are correctly labeled -


    we’ve had Madre Perla for 12+ years - never sealed it, still looks new (my fabricator had never heard of it back then so I paid the same install price as granite, he joked that he would never do that again)

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    Quartz is 33% plastic by volume, the weight percentages sales guys spout are worthless. Test anything labelled quartzite with a glass tile scratch test and a lemon juice acid test. It's a natural stone. You personally should figure out the layout for the cuts and seams. Or require your OK. And you should inspect the product before it leaves the shop. Quartzite is very hard and uses up diamond cutting tools faster. Inspect cuts for chips from dull cutting tools. If you want a leathered finish, it should already be that way from the manufacturer.

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    "Test anything labelled quartzite with a glass tile scratch test and a lemon juice acid test."


    Excellent advice, however a porosity test is essential unless you'd like to join the catastrophy club here.


    https://usenaturalstone.org/how-to-be-your-own-stone-sleuth/

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    Not all quartzite is the same, specially the "white" or light gray ones, which are prone to be mislabeled and are really marble or dolomite. Hardness alone does not make it a quartzite.

    I've had Taj Mahal quartzite counters in 2 kitchens, a fireplace surround and an outdoor kitchen counter & backsplash. The Taj Mahal slab backsplash behind the outdoor grill gets covered in grease and soot. I clean it every few months and all the grease/soot comes off with regular cleaning products. The only issue is that the pieces used outside were remnants and had a bit more filler/epoxy than I would have liked. That will be the weak point with the high heat exposure, but it has held up so far without any issues, after 2 years of use.

    I have quartz counters in my bathrooms and laundry room and have been very happy with those too.

  • PRO
    2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    Your material selections should fit the monetary level of your home.

    It doesn't make sense to take a standard tract home in suburbia and place quartzite counters in the kitchen. It's a waste of money.

    Good design can be accomplished with modest materials. Do not discount using Corian & plastic laminate. No one should be a slave to the materials they select for a kitchen.







  • PRO
    2 years ago

    If you are looking for something all white - I would look at Corian. I had a Corian top once and loved it! I currently have a quartz top ( Silestone ) for 20 years. I only have 1 chip and no other issues. I have never had quartzite - only read a lot of scary stories and a bunch of good stories ( most mentioning Taj Mahal ) .

    Good luck!

  • 2 years ago

    ^Another vote for Corian, we are building a vacation home this next year and I want something super simple and will be doing white Corian

  • 2 years ago

    Wow! I appreciate all of your comments and input. Thank you so much for taking the time to help I truly appreciate it.

  • 2 years ago

    Basically they all have pros and cons...we love our white quartz with subtle veining. I think the trick is to find one that is subtle, some of them are way overdone and fake looking. Go to a place where you can see the whole slab in person. The quartzite I saw was gorgeous but most were too busy for the look we were going for. That's just personal preference. Quartz is not totally heat proof so that's a consideration. We have translucent silicone pads around for hot pans. It is very stain resistant.

  • 2 years ago

    “I think the trick is to find one that is subtle, some of them are way overdone and fake looking.”

    All quartz trying to mimic marble, fails miserably. They all look fake…even the ”subtle” ones. Actual marble has a chrystalized depth and beauty, that plastic resin filled quartz cannot duplicate. Period.

  • 2 years ago

    You're entitled to your opinion, love the look of marble more certainly but it's not practical in our home. I searched far and wide and there's a lot of ugly quartz out there but you can find some attractive ones. In my opinion any way.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    I can appreciate all the materials available for counters ... they meet the many different needs/wants of homeowners. No need to put down a material you don't like.

    Over the years I have used quartzite, granite, limestone, quartz and corian for counters. They all have their pros and cons, but design wise, one isn't better than the other, just a different design choice.

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    We know nothing regarding the rest of your kitchen - Cabinet paint or stain, flooring, etc

    There's a pro or con for every material but Corian ( the original Dupont ) has a bunch of plain whites. Designer White, Cameo White, and more.

    It seams invisibly, lasts years and years and fine scratches 20 years later can be buffed out.

    It only fell from favor when the dark spotty granites emerged in the nineties. I have Cameo White and love it. Kitchen and bath.

  • 2 years ago

    Here's some solid surface options. Clearance - Sales | SolidSurface.com If you aren't attracted to marble-look quartz.