I think you need to consider the brown roof & what looks like brown windows.

BM Wenge

Behr Cracked Pepper

I agree. You have a brown roof, and the gray on the house does not go with the brown roof at all. Maybe an actual color on the siding, rather than something in the beige tones. A light sage green would go well with the brown roof.

@jck910 thank you! I am intrigued by the behr cracked pepper you shared. It looks like a warm dark grey to me. Did you mean for this to be a trim color or siding color? if trim, what siding?

• @cat_ky Re: The light sage green -- Looking for something more neutral than that green, it's just a personal preference .... but thx for your comment.

I would do a shade of sage green for the siding and a shade of burnt or sunset orange for the front door. You'll have to get lots of samples for both to see which look best on the house and together! Have fun with it - you have a great house.

IMO, none of the current colors work well together, especially the ’camp green’ that appears to be aqua.

You say you like gray - why not try a much paler, warmer tone of gray for the house body to cut down its contrast with the brown roof.

I love the wooded setting.

I was sitting outside an office building waiting for my husband to come out and noticed this house across the way. I’d call this color a subtle cornflower blue. The shutters and door are painted the exact color of the roof and the trim is cream.

I don't think gray works with the roof color. You need to go in an earth-tone direction, IMO. Taupe siding with beige trim and a burgundy door would be lovely.

A suggestion:

Siding: BM Huntington Beige

Trim:

BM Monterey White:

Door/Accents:

BM Country Redwood:

P.S. That top image looks metallic, but it isn't. Get paint samples and see them in person. Computer images are often misleading.

Thank you all for your responses… Lots to think about!