Software
Houzz Logo Print
dersch_propertiesllc

Need Window recommendation: Millworkman, Im looking in your direction

2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago

Looking for recommendations for replacement windows, and hoping Millworkman (and others in the know) would be so kind as to offer some expert insight. We want aluminum clad / wood. I'm in Wisconsin, and based on an admittedly less-than-exhaustive look at reviews and available suppliers in my area, I think I have it narrowed down, in no particular order, to Kolbe (Ultra), Weather Shield (Signature), Alliance (whichever series is the Al clad wood), or Anderson (E-Series). It's for a south facing three-season porch with a lot of sun exposure that we are converting to a year-round environmentally controlled room. Vinyl, fiberglass, and other composites have been ruled out- we want wood and aluminum. Any window by Marvin has been ruled out for reasons I don't care to discuss at this time.

You'll probably cringe when I mention that I'm going to have the interior wood part of it factory primed and painted. I'm sorry, but the boss (wife) says that's the way it's going to be, so let's not dwell on it and and just move on. So, given that it'll be painted, is there any sense in springing for a premium wood species like douglas fir, or should we stick with whatever stock pine they use as a base option?

Of the brands I mentioned, which one would you recommend based on durability under seasonal temperature extremes, reliability / longevity, warranty, and the manufacturers track record of making things right if there's a problem? I am also open to considering window brands other than those I mentioned (again, except Marvin) if you feel like there are better options out there I should be looking at instead, but of course that is predicated on them being available in my area and comparable in price. Finally, are there any other suggestions you would have in terms of special requests I might make for the construction of the window (joinery, low-e coatings, etc?) Expert input is greatly appreciated!!

Comments (11)

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    Unrelated to your question but why are Fiberglass and Composite out?


    Of that list, the E Series of the Kolbe. I've personally seen no data to indicate that any species of wood that is commonly used in window construction is going to last any longer than another in these cases. If the window is put together wrong or poorly designed...it's gonna rot out and fail.


    In your climate zone, proper air circulation, triple pane, and humidity management are going to be the bigger issues to longevity.

    Dersch Properties LLC thanked Windows on Washington Ltd
  • 2 years ago

    What ^^^^ he said. I would steer way clear of the Weathershield and or Alliance if the choice were mine.

    Dersch Properties LLC thanked millworkman
  • 2 years ago

    agree with both of the above....

    Dersch Properties LLC thanked oberon476
  • 2 years ago

    Thanks for the quick responses! I really appreciate your input. If you care to expound on why Anderson E, or Kolbe would be your choice over the others I'd certainly be interested. And, if price were more or less the same, I'm curious which of those two would you choose over the other (and why?)


    I may come back and elucidate why we're focusing on wood/aluminum over vinyls and composites, but it's more typing than I want to do at the moment.


    Thanks again!

  • 2 years ago

    Weathershield is and always has been lacking in fit & finish, quality control and customer service. Alliance seems to me to be a series of local guys selling under one name, so it will really be pot luck.

    Dersch Properties LLC thanked millworkman
  • 2 years ago

    Gotcha. Okay, so between Anderson E, and Kolbe Ultra, (assuming similar price), which one would you go with?


    Also, in a different post- from some years ago, I think- you had suggested to someone they should request some particular type of joinery for their wood windows, although I don't know if that was for an all-wood, or Al clad. I can't seem to find that particular thread anymore. Any thoughts on that?

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    I think those are fairly similar in terms of reputationally. I know the Kolbe was previously thought of as a premium, but I don't see it as that much better than the best Andersen product. Full disclaimer, wood isn't our lead out product so we don't do much of it and the section that we do is mostly Marvin.

    Dersch Properties LLC thanked Windows on Washington Ltd
  • 2 years ago

    I agree with Windows on Washington, and I do not do residential any longer so not 100% in the wood window loop daily I still have many friends how are.

  • 2 years ago

    Hi Guys, just wanted to revisit this quickly now that I have several quotes in hand. Based on your comments I've narrowed it down to just Kolbe or Anderson. The best bid for Anderson E-Series (pine) is 1355$ per window (not including installation). It's 1123$ per window for the Kolbe Ultra (also pine). One place seems to be trying to steer me toward Anderson's A-Series, which would be about 300$ cheaper per window (vs the E-Series. Only about 100$ less than the Kolbe). It's also interesting to note that for Anderson, the upgrade to Fir adds a couple hundred $ per window, while with Kolbe, the difference is marginal- about 60 bucks per window. Keep in mind, I'll be buying NINE windows, so every cost differential should be multiplied by 9x.


    So, I wanted your input before I make any final decisions:

    1) Are these prices reasonable, or should I be looking for more bids?

    2-a) Now that you know the price differences, would you recommend going with the slightly less expensive Kolbe Ultra over the E-Series?

    2-b) I've heard from multiple suppliers that due to the simple fact that Anderson is a much larger company, the availability of their parts and service personnel, if needed, is much better. But I'm not sure if that's true. I mean, Kolbe is a Wisconsin company, and that's where I am, so it would seem like that shouldn't be an issue, but what do I know? Any experience or thoughts on that?

    3). In view of the fact that that the A-Series would be less expensive yet, would that be a reasonable option that I should consider, or is there a quality deficit there that makes it not worth the savings?

    4) If I go with the Kolbe, given that the Fir is only marginally more expensive, is it worth it, or do you still feel the wood species still offers no appreciable difference (i.e. pine is perfectly suitable)? Keep in mind, regardless of species, they are going to be painted white.

    5) I do wonder if the fact that Anderson is generally more popular, makes it a better option from the perspective of installation. I mean, it stands to reason that whatever installer I go with, they likely have more experience with Anderson over Kolbe, and therefore I might get a better installation with the Anderson. Or maybe I'm over-thinking this aspect of it? I welcome your thoughts.


    Thanks again guys! Looking forward to your insight.

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    The A-series is nice and I prefer it over the E-Series. If you are just pricing out material I would get more bids as it

    much easier then sitting through a sales pitch. Prices can vary alot, and getting a quote is as simple as an email. Just gotta make sure the quotes are the same.

Sponsored
Kuhns Contracting, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Central Ohio's Trusted Home Remodeler Specializing in Kitchens & Baths